1.8.1 · D5Electromagnetism
Question bank — Electric charge — properties, quantization, conservation
Before we start, the symbols and units we lean on:
Two schematic pictures we will point back to:


True or false — justify
True or false: A charged body always has fewer electrons than protons.
False — a negatively charged body has more electrons than protons; only a positive body has fewer. "Charged" just means the counts don't match, either way.
True or false: If two objects carry equal and opposite charge and , the total charge of the pair is zero.
True — additivity means , where is just the shared magnitude. The system as a whole is neutral even though each piece is charged.
True or false: Charge conservation means the charge on each individual object stays fixed.
False — only the total of the isolated system is fixed. Individual objects freely swap charge (that is exactly what touching conductors do — see figure 2).
True or false: You can transfer exactly electrons' worth of charge between two bodies.
False — you can only move whole electrons, so transferred charge is always with an integer. Half an electron is not a thing you can hand over.
True or false: Rubbing glass with silk creates positive charge out of nothing.
False — it separates existing charge by transferring electrons from glass to silk. Glass ends up positive, silk negative; nothing is created (see Methods of Charging).
True or false: A neutral object contains no charge at all.
False — it contains equal amounts of positive and negative charge that cancel in the total. "Neutral" means balanced, not empty.
True or false: Because quarks carry , the smallest possible free charge is .
False — quarks are confined and never observed alone. Any free, isolatable particle carries an integer multiple of , so the free-charge brick stays .
True or false: Charge is a vector because it produces an electric force, which has direction.
False — charge is a signed scalar; the force gets its direction from the geometry of where charges sit, not from charge itself (see Coulomb's Law).
True or false: In pair production a lone photon in empty vacuum can turn into an electron and a positron.
False for vacuum — charge balances (), but energy and momentum cannot both be conserved unless a nearby nucleus absorbs recoil. It needs matter present (figure 1).
Spot the error
Spot the error: "To make a rod positive, we add protons to it."
Protons are locked in nuclei and don't move in ordinary processes. You make a rod positive by removing electrons, exposing the protons already there.
Spot the error: "Two spheres with and touch; each ends with — so charge was destroyed."
Nothing was destroyed. Total was before and after ( each); sharing redistributes, it does not delete.
Spot the error: "Charging by induction adds charge to the object being charged from a distance."
Induction rearranges the object's own charge (or grounds part of it away); no charge jumps across the gap without contact. Total of the isolated set-up is still conserved.
Spot the error: "A body carries , which is fine because it's positive."
, not — so it is actually and perfectly allowed. A genuine non-integer would be forbidden by quantization, but this one is integer.
Spot the error: "Conservation of charge is a special rule for electricity, unlike other conservation laws."
It sits alongside energy and momentum as a fundamental Conservation Laws in Physics result, tied to a deep symmetry — not a one-off electrical convenience.
Spot the error: "When a conductor is grounded, its charge is destroyed."
The charge flows into the Earth, an enormous reservoir; it is relocated, not destroyed. The Earth-plus-conductor total is unchanged.
Why questions
Why does charge come in two types rather than one?
One type could only ever attract (like mass in gravity). Two signs are needed so that like charges repel and unlike charges attract, matching experiment.
Why is quantization invisible in everyday life?
The brick is so tiny that a charge is electrons; the step between and looks smooth, like sand looking like fluid from afar.
Why do we add charges with signs instead of head-to-tail like vectors?
Charge has magnitude and a sign but no direction, so it is a scalar. A and a give , not .
Why must pair production happen near a nucleus?
A lone photon converting to two particles cannot conserve energy and momentum simultaneously; a massive third body absorbs the recoil momentum so both are satisfied while charge stays balanced at zero.
Why can identical spheres be assumed to split charge equally on contact?
For any conductor the charge it holds is , so its potential is , where (its capacitance) depends only on size and shape. Identical spheres have identical ; on contact they must reach one common , and with equal and equal forces equal — hence the total splits in half.
Edge cases
Edge case: Can the total charge of an isolated system be exactly zero yet the system still exert internal forces?
Yes — a neutral system can hold separated and regions (a dipole) whose parts still push and pull each other; net charge zero, internal forces nonzero.
Edge case: Is (a truly neutral body) consistent with ?
Yes — is the case. Quantization allows zero; neutral is just the integer multiple with .
Edge case: If you keep removing electrons from a metal ball, can its charge grow without limit?
No practical limit from charge law itself, but eventually the field gets strong enough to pull charge back (sparking/breakdown), so a real ball caps out physically, not because forbids it.
Edge case: Two spheres and touch — can they end at exactly each?
No — total is , and is not an integer multiple of . In practice a real conductor holds billions of bricks, so the sharing is only ever off by at most one whole electron: the two spheres settle at and (or the reverse), with that single leftover brick sitting on one sphere — a difference far too small to measure at macroscopic scales.
Edge case: Does charge conservation hold during radioactive beta decay, where a neutron becomes a proton?
Yes — a neutron () decays to a proton (), an electron (), and an antineutrino (); total charge before and after is . The bookkeeping balances exactly (see Atomic Structure).
Recall One-line summary of every trap here
Charge is a signed scalar (add algebraically), the total of a sealed system is fixed (individuals swap freely), and free charge always comes in whole -bricks (with meaning neutral). Every trap above is one of these three truths in disguise.