1.6.13 · D5Oscillations & Waves
Question bank — Mechanical waves — transverse and longitudinal
True or false — justify
A wave carries matter from source to destination.
False. Each particle only oscillates about its rest spot; it is the pattern (and its energy/momentum) that travels, not the medium's matter.
A mechanical wave can travel through a perfect vacuum.
False. The disturbance is handed on by inter-particle forces (elasticity) and mass (inertia); with no particles there is nothing to pass it along.
Sound can travel as a transverse wave through the open air.
False. Air has no shear rigidity, so it cannot support sideways-vibration waves in its bulk — sound in air is purely longitudinal.
A solid can carry both transverse and longitudinal waves.
True. A solid resists both shear (→ transverse) and compression (→ longitudinal), so both wave types propagate through it.
In , increasing the frequency increases the wave speed.
False. In a non-dispersive medium is fixed by the medium; raising just ==shortens == to keep the product constant.
The textbook sine curve drawn for sound means sound is transverse.
False. That curve plots pressure (or displacement) versus position, not sideways motion — sound stays longitudinal.
At a crest of a transverse wave, the particle's speed is maximum.
False. At a crest the particle is momentarily at rest (turning point of SHM); its speed is maximum at the equilibrium line, where .
Two waves of the same speed but different frequency have the same wavelength.
False. Since and is common, the higher-frequency wave has the shorter wavelength.
Doubling the tension in a string doubles the wave speed.
False. , so double tension gives only a factor increase — the square root tames it. (See Wave equation.)
The particle velocity and the wave velocity always point the same way.
False. Particle velocity is transverse (up/down) for a transverse wave while wave velocity is along ; they are perpendicular, and even reverses sign each half cycle.
Spot the error
"Sound needs a medium because sound is made of tiny particles that fly to your ear."
Error: sound isn't flying particles. Air molecules only jostle their neighbours back and forth; the compression pattern travels, the molecules stay local. (See Sound waves.)
"A cork on a passing water wave drifts steadily toward the shore, proving the water moves with the wave."
Error: the cork mostly traces a small closed loop and returns; only energy crosses the pool. Any tiny net drift is a second-order effect, not the wave itself.
" lets a loud singer raise the wave speed by singing more powerfully."
Error: loudness is amplitude, not frequency or speed; depends only on the medium and adjusts to , never to amplitude.
"Since , the wave speed is ."
Error: is the maximum particle speed, an up/down quantity. The wave (pattern) speed is — a different formula and meaning.
"For the wave moves in the direction."
Error: the sign means the phase is constant when decreases as increases, so this wave travels in the direction. The -moving wave is .
"The wave equation term means faraway particles lead the source."
Error: the minus sign is a delay: the particle at does now what the source did a time ago, so it lags, not leads.
"A denser string always carries a faster wave because dense means strong."
Error: density here is inertia, in the denominator: , so larger mass-per-length makes the wave slower, not faster.
Why questions
Why must a transverse wave's medium resist shear but a longitudinal one only resist compression?
To pull a neighbour sideways you need a force that opposes shape change (shear); to pull it along the line you only need resistance to being squeezed (compression), which every gas/liquid/solid has.
Why does raising the source frequency shorten the wavelength instead of speeding the wave up?
The medium fixes , and must hold, so if rises then must fall to keep constant.
Why is wave speed written as and not their sum or product?
A stronger restoring force snaps particles back faster (numerator) while more inertia makes them sluggish (denominator); the square-root form is what falls out of Newton's law on a medium element. (See Wave equation.)
Why does the pattern move while every particle stays put?
Each particle simply copies its neighbour's motion a tiny moment later, so the shape advances even though no particle leaves its own neighbourhood — the stadium "Mexican wave" idea.
Why is the particle velocity linked to the slope of the snapshot by ?
Both derivatives of share the same cosine, and their ratio is ; the minus sign says a particle on a rising-to-the-right part of the curve is moving downward as the wave slides forward.
Why can two different sources produce the same wavelength in one medium but different wavelengths in another?
; the same gives the same only when is the same, and changes with the medium's stiffness and density.
Edge cases
What happens to a transverse wave sent into the bulk of a still lake?
It cannot propagate through the bulk — a fluid has no shear rigidity, so only longitudinal (sound) waves survive in the interior. (Surface water waves are a special mixed case, not bulk transverse.)
If the amplitude , is there still a wave?
No meaningful disturbance remains: everywhere, so there is no energy to transport even though , , are still defined.
If tension on a string, what happens to the wave speed?
— with no restoring force the disturbance cannot be handed on, so no wave travels.
If two identical waves travel in opposite directions on the same string, do they still each obey ?
Yes — each travelling wave keeps its own ; their sum forms a standing pattern, but that superposition doesn't change either wave's speed. (See Standing waves & resonance and Superposition and Interference.)
At the exact instant a particle passes through equilibrium (), what are its speed and acceleration?
Speed is maximum () and acceleration is zero, because restoring force vanishes at — the SHM signature. (See Simple Harmonic Motion.)
For a listener moving relative to a sound source, does the medium's wave speed change?
No — is fixed by the air; the observed frequency shifts (Doppler) while the wave speed through the medium stays the same. (See Doppler effect.)
If a wave passes from a light string into a heavier one at fixed tension, what stays constant across the join?
The frequency is set by the source and is continuous, but drops (larger ) so shortens in the heavier string.