1.6.9Oscillations & Waves

Damped oscillations — underdamped, critically damped, overdamped

1,951 words9 min readdifficulty · medium6 backlinks

WHAT are we describing?

WHY velocity-proportional? Because viscous drag (a body moving slowly through fluid/air) really does scale with speed — slow motion through honey resists harder the faster you push. It's the simplest and physically common case, so we start here.


HOW to derive the equation of motion

Newton's second law: mx¨=Fm\ddot{x} = \sum F. Forces are spring kx-kx and damping bx˙-b\dot{x}:

mx¨=kxbx˙m\ddot{x} = -kx - b\dot{x}

Move everything to one side and divide by mm:

x¨+bmx˙+kmx=0\ddot{x} + \frac{b}{m}\dot{x} + \frac{k}{m}x = 0

Why this step? Dividing by mm exposes the two physically meaningful frequencies. We define:

Why the factor 2 in 2γ2\gamma? Pure convenience — it makes later square roots come out clean (γ2ω02\sqrt{\gamma^2-\omega_0^2} with no extra factors).

Solve by guessing exponentials

A linear constant-coefficient ODE is solved by x=eλtx = e^{\lambda t}. Why this guess? Because differentiation just multiplies eλte^{\lambda t} by λ\lambda, turning calculus into algebra. Substitute:

λ2+2γλ+ω02=0(characteristic equation)\lambda^2 + 2\gamma\lambda + \omega_0^2 = 0 \quad\text{(characteristic equation)}

Quadratic formula:

λ=γ±γ2ω02\lambda = -\gamma \pm \sqrt{\gamma^2 - \omega_0^2}

Everything hinges on the sign of γ2ω02\gamma^2 - \omega_0^2 — i.e. on whether the discriminant is negative, zero, or positive. That single sign creates the three regimes.


The three regimes

WHY oscillation? The imaginary part of λ\lambda is an oscillation (Euler: eiωdte^{i\omega_d t} = sines/cosines); the real part γ-\gamma is the decay. The spring still wins the "wobble" fight, but every swing is smaller.

WHY slow? The slower root λ1=γ+γ2ω02\lambda_1 = -\gamma + \sqrt{\gamma^2-\omega_0^2} is small in magnitude (close to 0), so that term lingers a long time. Heavy damping makes the system sluggish, like a door closer set too tight.

WHY the extra tt? With a repeated root, eλte^{\lambda t} alone gives only ONE solution, but a 2nd-order ODE needs TWO. Multiplying by tt produces a genuinely independent second solution (you can verify it satisfies the ODE).

WHY is critical damping special/useful? It's the borderline. Any less damping ⇒ overshoot/wobble; any more ⇒ sluggish. So it's the fastest non-oscillatory settling — exactly what you want for car suspensions, analog meter needles, and door closers.

Figure — Damped oscillations — underdamped, critically damped, overdamped

Energy & "how damped is it?" — the Quality factor

Energy in an underdamped oscillator decays because amplitude eγt\propto e^{-\gamma t} and energy \propto amplitude²:

E(t)=E0e2γtE(t) = E_0\, e^{-2\gamma t}

Why the 2? Energy 12kA2\sim \tfrac12 k A^2, and A2(eγt)2=e2γtA^2 \to (e^{-\gamma t})^2 = e^{-2\gamma t}.


Worked examples


Common mistakes (steel-manned)


Recall Feynman: explain to a 12-year-old

Imagine pushing a kid on a swing, then walking away. Normally they'd keep swinging a long time. Now imagine the swing is moving through thick syrup instead of air.

  • A little syrup: the kid still swings back and forth, but each swing is smaller and smaller until they stop. (underdamped)
  • The perfect amount of syrup: the swing glides smoothly back to the middle and stops — no back-and-forth, and as fast as possible. (critically damped)
  • Way too much syrup: the swing oozes back to the middle super slowly, like moving through cold honey. (overdamped) The syrup is the "damping." How thick it is decides which of the three things happens.

Flashcards

What force model defines a (linearly) damped oscillator?
A resistive force opposing velocity, F=bx˙F=-b\dot x.
Write the standard-form damped ODE.
x¨+2γx˙+ω02x=0\ddot x + 2\gamma\dot x + \omega_0^2 x = 0 with γ=b/2m\gamma=b/2m, ω0=k/m\omega_0=\sqrt{k/m}.
What is the characteristic equation and its roots?
λ2+2γλ+ω02=0\lambda^2+2\gamma\lambda+\omega_0^2=0λ=γ±γ2ω02\lambda=-\gamma\pm\sqrt{\gamma^2-\omega_0^2}.
Condition for underdamped, and its solution?
γ<ω0\gamma<\omega_0; x=Aeγtcos(ωdt+ϕ)x=Ae^{-\gamma t}\cos(\omega_d t+\phi) with ωd=ω02γ2\omega_d=\sqrt{\omega_0^2-\gamma^2}.
Condition for overdamped, and its solution?
γ>ω0\gamma>\omega_0; x=Aeλ1t+Beλ2tx=Ae^{\lambda_1 t}+Be^{\lambda_2 t}, both roots real & negative, no oscillation.
Condition for critically damped, and solution form?
γ=ω0\gamma=\omega_0; x=(A+Bt)eγtx=(A+Bt)e^{-\gamma t}.
Why does critical damping have a teγtt e^{-\gamma t} term?
Repeated root gives only one exponential; a 2nd independent solution is needed for a 2nd-order ODE.
What is the damped frequency ωd\omega_d?
ωd=ω02γ2\omega_d=\sqrt{\omega_0^2-\gamma^2} (always <ω0<\omega_0).
Which regime returns to equilibrium fastest without overshoot?
Critically damped.
How does energy decay in an underdamped oscillator?
E(t)=E0e2γtE(t)=E_0 e^{-2\gamma t} (since EA2E\propto A^2, amplitude eγt\propto e^{-\gamma t}).
Quality factor definition and critical value?
Q=ω0/(2γ)Q=\omega_0/(2\gamma); Q=1/2Q=1/2 at critical damping.
Find bb for critical damping given m,km,k.
bcrit=2km=2mω0b_{crit}=2\sqrt{km}=2m\omega_0.

Connections

  • Simple Harmonic Motion — the γ=0\gamma=0 limit (ωdω0\omega_d\to\omega_0, no decay).
  • Forced Oscillations & Resonance — add a driving force; damping sets resonance sharpness (QQ).
  • Second-order linear ODEs — the characteristic-root method used here.
  • Quality factor & bandwidth — how QQ links damping to resonance width.
  • RLC circuits — electrical twin: Lq¨+Rq˙+q/C=0L\ddot q + R\dot q + q/C=0, same three regimes.

Concept Map

models loss as

opposes velocity

divide by m

defines

defines

guess e^lambda t

quadratic formula

sign of discriminant

gamma < omega0

gamma = omega0

gamma > omega0

damped freq omega_d

Real world steals energy

Damping force -b x-dot

Newton 2nd law m x-ddot = -kx - b x-dot

Standard form x-ddot + 2 gamma x-dot + omega0^2 x = 0

Damping coeff gamma = b/2m

Natural freq omega0 = sqrt k/m

Characteristic eqn

lambda = -gamma +/- sqrt gamma^2 - omega0^2

Compare gamma vs omega0

Underdamped wobbles down

Critically damped fastest return

Overdamped slow no wobble

Shrinking envelope decay

Hinglish (regional understanding)

Intuition Hinglish mein samjho

Socho ek spring pe lagi mass jhool rahi hai. Agar koi friction na ho to woh hamesha oscillate karti rahegi. Lekin real life mein air drag ya viscous friction velocity ke against ek force lagati hai — ise hum F=bx˙F=-b\dot x likhte hain. Newton's law lagao to equation banta hai x¨+2γx˙+ω02x=0\ddot x + 2\gamma\dot x + \omega_0^2 x = 0, jahan γ=b/2m\gamma=b/2m (kitna damping) aur ω0=k/m\omega_0=\sqrt{k/m} (spring ki natural frequency).

Ab pura khel ek hi cheez pe depend karta hai: γ\gamma bada hai ya ω0\omega_0 bada hai. Iske teen cases hain. Underdamped (γ<ω0\gamma<\omega_0): mass abhi bhi aage-peeche jhoolti hai par har swing chhoti hoti jaati hai, jaise ek shrinking envelope eγte^{-\gamma t} ke andar. Critically damped (γ=ω0\gamma=\omega_0): bina jhoole, seedha aur sabse jaldi equilibrium pe aa jaati hai. Overdamped (γ>ω0\gamma>\omega_0): bohot zyada friction, isliye dheere-dheere, syrup mein chalne ki tarah, slowly wapas aati hai — koi oscillation nahi.

Yaad rakhne ka simple test: kam damping → wobble karta hai, zyada damping → crawl karta hai, exactly barabar → fastest clean stop. Critical damping isliye important hai kyunki car ke shock absorbers, door closers, aur meter ki needle sabko yahi chahiye — jaldi settle ho, par overshoot na kare.

Energy ke liye: amplitude eγte^{-\gamma t} se girti hai, aur energy amplitude ka square hoti hai, isliye E=E0e2γtE=E_0 e^{-2\gamma t}. Quality factor Q=ω0/2γQ=\omega_0/2\gamma batata hai system kitni baar "ring" karega — tuning fork ka QQ bohot high hota hai isliye lambi der tak bajta hai.

Go deeper — visual, from zero

Test yourself — Oscillations & Waves

Connections