1.3.8Work, Energy & Power

Conservation of mechanical energy — derivation

1,932 words9 min readdifficulty · medium6 backlinks

WHAT are we proving?

The claim: If only conservative forces do work, then E=K+UE = K + U is constant in time.


WHY should this even be true? (the engine of the proof)

Two facts do all the heavy lifting:

  1. Work–energy theorem (from Newton's 2nd law): net work = change in kinetic energy.
  2. Definition of potential energy: the work done by a conservative force is minus the change in its potential energy.

Put those side by side and the result falls out. Let's derive each piece from scratch.


HOW — Derivation from first principles

Step 1 — Work–energy theorem

Start from Newton's second law in one dimension, Fnet=ma=mdvdtF_{net} = ma = m\dfrac{dv}{dt}.

The net work done as the object moves a small displacement dxdx: dWnet=Fnetdx=mdvdtdxdW_{net} = F_{net}\,dx = m\frac{dv}{dt}\,dx

So: dWnet=mvdvdW_{net} = m\,v\,dv

Integrate from state 1 (v1v_1) to state 2 (v2v_2): Wnet=v1v2mvdv=12mv2212mv12=ΔKW_{net} = \int_{v_1}^{v_2} m\,v\,dv = \tfrac{1}{2}mv_2^2 - \tfrac{1}{2}mv_1^2 = \Delta K

Step 2 — Potential energy from a conservative force

For a conservative force, we define potential energy so that the work it does equals the drop in potential energy: Wcons=ΔU=(U2U1)W_{cons} = -\Delta U = -(U_2 - U_1)

For gravity near Earth, F=mgF = -mg (down). The work it does moving from height h1h_1 to h2h_2: Wgrav=h1h2(mg)dh=mg(h2h1)=(mgh2mgh1)W_{grav} = \int_{h_1}^{h_2}(-mg)\,dh = -mg(h_2 - h_1) = -(mgh_2 - mgh_1) Comparing with Wcons=ΔUW_{cons} = -\Delta U gives the familiar U=mghU = mgh. We derived it, not assumed it.

Step 3 — Combine

If the only force doing work is conservative, then Wnet=WconsW_{net} = W_{cons}. Set Step 1 equal to Step 2: ΔK=Wnet=Wcons=ΔU\Delta K = W_{net} = W_{cons} = -\Delta U

ΔK+ΔU=0Δ(K+U)=0\boxed{\Delta K + \Delta U = 0 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \Delta(K+U)=0}

Figure — Conservation of mechanical energy — derivation

Forecast-then-Verify

Recall Forecast before reading the answer

A ball is dropped from rest at height hh. Predict its speed at the ground using energy conservation, then verify with kinematics.

Energy: K1+U1=K2+U20+mgh=12mv2+0v=2ghK_1+U_1 = K_2+U_2 \Rightarrow 0 + mgh = \tfrac12 mv^2 + 0 \Rightarrow v=\sqrt{2gh}. Kinematics: v2=u2+2gh=0+2ghv=2ghv^2 = u^2 + 2gh = 0 + 2gh \Rightarrow v=\sqrt{2gh}. ✓ Same answer — energy method skipped time entirely.


Worked examples


Common mistakes (Steel-manned)


Recall Feynman: explain to a 12-year-old

Think of energy like pocket money you can keep in two pockets: a "moving" pocket (kinetic) and a "stored-up" pocket (potential — like being high up or a squished spring). When a ball falls, money slides from the "high-up" pocket into the "moving" pocket — but the total money in your two pockets never changes. The only way to lose money is if a sticky thief called friction grabs some and turns it into heat. No friction, no thief → your total stays exactly the same forever.


Flashcards

What is mechanical energy?
The sum of kinetic and potential energy, E=K+UE=K+U.
State the work–energy theorem.
The net work done on an object equals its change in kinetic energy, Wnet=ΔKW_{net}=\Delta K.
How is potential energy defined from a conservative force?
As the negative of the work done by that force: Wcons=ΔUW_{cons}=-\Delta U.
Under what condition is mechanical energy conserved?
When the only forces doing work are conservative (no net work by non-conservative forces like friction).
Derive vv of an object dropped from height hh using energy.
mgh=12mv2v=2ghmgh=\tfrac12mv^2 \Rightarrow v=\sqrt{2gh}.
Why does the minus sign appear in Wcons=ΔUW_{cons}=-\Delta U?
So that work done by the force and the change in stored PE have opposite signs (force does +work ⇒ PE drops).
Why is energy conservation easier than kinematics here?
It eliminates time and force direction; you only compare two states.
What replaces ΔE=0\Delta E=0 when friction is present?
Δ(K+U)=Wnc\Delta(K+U)=W_{nc}, the work done by non-conservative forces (negative for friction).
Why does string tension do no work on a pendulum?
It is always perpendicular to the bob's velocity, so Fd=0\vec F\cdot\vec d=0.
Spring potential energy formula and its derivation source?
U=12kx2U=\tfrac12kx^2, from 0x(kx)dx-\int_0^x(-kx')dx'.

Connections

Concept Map

integrate over dx

swaps t for v

net work = ΔK

path independent

W_cons = minus ΔU

for gravity F=-mg

only conservative force

substitute

ΔK + ΔU = 0

defines

excluded, breaks

Newtons second law F=ma

Work-energy theorem

Chain rule dx = v dt

W_net = ΔK

Conservative force

Define potential energy

W_cons = -ΔU

U = mgh derived

Combine steps

E = K + U constant

Mechanical energy conserved

Friction non-conservative

Hinglish (regional understanding)

Intuition Hinglish mein samjho

Socho ek ball ko tum upar se neeche girate ho. Jaise-jaise woh girti hai, uski speed badhti jaati hai — yaani kinetic energy badh rahi hai. Par saath hi uski height kam ho rahi hai — yaani potential energy (mghmgh) ghat rahi hai. Kamaal ki baat ye hai ki jitni PE kam hoti hai, bilkul utni hi KE badh jaati hai. Energy gayab nahi hoti, sirf ek roop se doosre roop mein badalti hai. Dono ka total — jise hum mechanical energy kehte hain — same rehta hai. Bas yahi conservation of mechanical energy hai.

Iska proof do simple cheezon se aata hai. Pehla: work-energy theorem, jo Newton ke second law se aata hai — net work = change in kinetic energy (Wnet=ΔKW_{net}=\Delta K). Doosra: conservative force (jaise gravity ya spring) jo work karti hai woh PE ke change ka ulta hota hai (Wcons=ΔUW_{cons}=-\Delta U). Jab sirf conservative force kaam kar rahi ho, to Wnet=WconsW_{net}=W_{cons}, isse seedha ΔK=ΔU\Delta K = -\Delta U milta hai, yaani Δ(K+U)=0\Delta(K+U)=0. Total constant!

Sabse important baat — ye law tabhi chalta hai jab friction jaisi non-conservative force kaam na kare. Friction energy ko heat mein badal deta hai, jo K+UK+U se bahar nikal jaati hai. Isliye exam mein hamesha pehle check karo: "Kya yahan friction hai? Kya tension ya normal force motion ke perpendicular hai (toh unka work zero)?" Agar sirf gravity/spring kaam kar rahi hai, to bindaas K1+U1=K2+U2K_1+U_1=K_2+U_2 likh do.

Yeh method kyu useful hai? Kyunki ismein na time chahiye, na force ki direction ka tension. Sirf do states — start aur end — compare karo, aur answer mil jaata hai. Pendulum, spring, ramp — sab jagah ek hi trick.

Go deeper — visual, from zero

Test yourself — Work, Energy & Power

Connections