1.1.18 · D5Measurement, Vectors & Kinematics

Question bank — Graphs — x-t, v-t, a-t; areas and slopes meaning

1,254 words6 min readBack to topic

True or false — justify

Every straight line on an graph means constant velocity.
True — a straight line has constant slope, and slope of is velocity, so velocity is unchanging (even if the line is flat, giving ).
A horizontal line on an graph means constant velocity.
False — a flat line has slope , so ; the object is at rest, not cruising at constant speed.
A horizontal line on a graph means constant velocity.
True — flat means is unchanging in value, i.e. constant velocity (and its slope means ).
The area under any graph gives displacement.
False — integrating position over time gives units of , which is physically meaningless; for you take the slope, not the area.
If the area comes out negative, the object never actually moved.
False — negative area means net displacement is in the direction; the object certainly moved, just backward overall.
Net area under can be zero while the object travelled a large distance.
True — equal positive and negative areas cancel to give displacement , but the sum of their magnitudes (the distance) can be large.
A graph that stays above the axis guarantees displacement equals distance.
True — if throughout, velocity never reverses, so no area is subtracted and net area equals total area.
Two objects with the same graph must be at the same position at all times.
False — the graph fixes only changes in position (areas); different starting positions shift the whole curve up or down.
Steeper always means larger speed, regardless of sign.
True — speed is the magnitude of slope, so a steep line (up or down) means fast motion; only the direction differs.
Zero acceleration means the object is stationary.
False — means velocity is constant; that constant can be any nonzero value, so the object may be moving steadily.

Spot the error

"The line is negative for a while, so the object is decelerating there."
The sign of is direction, not deceleration; whether it slows depends on the slope () versus 's sign, not on being negative.
"I found the area under the curve to get the velocity."
Wrong operation — velocity is the slope of ; area under has no physical meaning (units ).
"On the graph I read the height to get ."
Height is the instantaneous acceleration; is the area under , i.e. accumulated acceleration over time.
"The ball at the top of its throw has because it momentarily stops."
At the top but throughout; the slope is unbroken through zero, so acceleration never vanishes.
"The graph curves upward, so the object is speeding up in the direction — always."
Upward curvature means ; that speeds up motion only if is also . If the object moves in (), actually slows it down.
"Below-axis area is negative, so I subtract it from displacement AND from distance."
For displacement you subtract (signed), but for distance you add its magnitude — distance ignores direction.
"The slope of the trapezium in derivation gives displacement."
The slope gives acceleration ; the area of that trapezium gives displacement — slopes and areas are different operations.

Why questions

Why is called "the most useful" graph?
Its slope gives and its area gives — both operations yield physically meaningful quantities, unlike (only slope) or (only area). See Differentiation and Integration in Physics.
Why does "slope slides down, area adds up" work as a memory rule?
Taking a slope moves you down the chain (differentiation), while accumulating area moves you back up (integration) — opposite operations, opposite directions.
Why does area under equal displacement rather than distance?
Each thin strip is , and carries a sign, so backward motion contributes negative strips; the signed sum is net displacement. See Distance vs Displacement.
Why can we treat the constant- region as a trapezium?
With constant acceleration the graph is a straight sloped line, so the region under it between two times is a trapezium (average height width). See Equations of Uniformly Accelerated Motion.
Why does the sign of tell direction but the sign of relative to tell speeding vs slowing?
's sign points the motion; whether grows depends on whether pushes with ( same sign) or against ( opposite) the motion.
Why does a curving line imply nonzero acceleration?
Curvature means the slope (velocity) is changing, and a changing velocity is exactly what acceleration measures.

Edge cases

What does a graph touching the time axis at a single instant tell you?
Velocity is momentarily zero there (e.g. top of a throw), but if the slope is nonzero the object immediately reverses — it does not rest. See Free Fall and Projectile Motion.
What is the displacement over one full symmetric up-and-down throw?
Zero — the positive area (going up) exactly cancels the equal negative area (coming down back to the start point).
What is the distance over that same throw?
Twice the maximum height — you sum the magnitudes of the equal up and down areas.
If the graph is a single spike of zero width, what is ?
Zero area means zero ; a genuine velocity jump needs finite area, so an infinitely thin spike changes nothing.
At a sharp corner (kink) on an graph, what is the velocity?
Undefined at that instant — the slope jumps, meaning velocity changes discontinuously, which requires infinite (idealised) acceleration. See Instantaneous vs Average Velocity.
What does a vertical segment on an graph mean physically?
It implies infinite slope, i.e. infinite velocity — physically impossible, so real graphs never go vertical.
What happens to distance vs displacement when never changes sign?
They become equal in magnitude, because no area is subtracted; sign changes in are the only thing that makes them differ. See Vectors — Components and Signs.