1.1.17 · D5Measurement, Vectors & Kinematics
Question bank — Free fall — g = 9.8 m - s², sign conventions
True or false — justify
True or false: In free fall, a heavier object hits the ground before a lighter one.
False (in vacuum). Since gives , the mass cancels and every object accelerates identically; the "heavier falls faster" effect you see in air is air resistance, not gravity.
True or false: An object thrown straight up is NOT in free fall while it is still moving upward.
False. Free fall means gravity is the only force — this is true on the way up, at the top, and on the way down. The object is decelerating, but only gravity is acting.
True or false: At the very top of a vertical throw the acceleration is momentarily zero.
False. Only the velocity is momentarily zero; the acceleration is still . If were zero the ball would hover there forever instead of coming back down.
True or false: If "up" is positive, then appears as in your equations.
False. Gravity points down, so with up positive the acceleration is . The number is a magnitude; the sign is decided by your chosen axis.
True or false: A ball thrown up returns to its launch height with the same speed it left.
True (no air). By the time-free relation with , the return speed magnitude equals — but the velocity is now (directed downward).
True or false: Choosing "down positive" changes the physics of the fall.
False. It only relabels which direction we call ; the actual motion is identical. With down positive we simply write and downward velocities as positive — see Vectors and sign conventions.
True or false: A ball dropped from rest and a ball thrown horizontally off the same cliff hit the ground at the same time.
True. Vertical and horizontal motion are independent; the vertical drop obeys regardless of horizontal speed. This is the core idea of Projectile Motion.
True or false: During free fall the velocity is always negative if we take up as positive.
False. On the way up the velocity is positive (moving up); it passes through zero at the top and only then becomes negative. The acceleration is negative throughout, not the velocity.
Spot the error
"At the top, , so by the object has stopped and stays there." — find the flaw.
The equation only says velocity is instantaneously zero at that instant ; a moment later is larger so becomes negative. Zero velocity is a passing instant, not a resting state.
"The ball speeds up by every metre it falls." — what's wrong?
is metres-per-second per second, not per metre. It gains of speed each second, not each metre of distance dropped.
"Since acceleration is , the ball must be moving downward the whole time." — error?
Acceleration direction and velocity direction are independent. On the way up while velocity is upward (positive); the negative acceleration is what slows the upward motion.
"For an object thrown down, I'll use up-positive but write because I threw it." — error?
Signs must match the chosen axis. If up is positive, a downward throw means ; writing mixes conventions and corrupts every later result.
"Max height is ." — what's missing?
A factor of . From we get ; the "2" from integrating the constant acceleration was dropped.
"Free fall requires the object to be falling, so a rocket coasting upward with engines off isn't in free fall." — flaw?
Free fall is defined by the forces, not the direction of motion. Engines off and no air means gravity alone acts, so the coasting rocket IS in free fall even while rising.
"Because both balls are in free fall, one dropped from 20 m and one from 5 m hit with the same speed." — error?
Same acceleration, not same impact speed. Impact speed depends on drop height via ; the 20 m ball arrives faster.
Why questions
Why does the mass of the object not appear in the free-fall acceleration?
Gravity's pull grows with mass (), but so does the resistance to being accelerated (). Setting cancels , leaving — the two mass effects exactly offset. See Newton's Second Law.
Why is time-up equal to time-down for a vertical throw?
The motion is symmetric: the same constant acceleration that removes speed on the way up restores exactly on the way down over the same height, so both legs take .
Why do we bother choosing a positive direction at all?
Because velocity, displacement, and acceleration are directional (vectors), and a sign is the 1-D way of encoding direction. Without a fixed convention "up" and "down" get mixed and equations give nonsense — Vectors and sign conventions.
Why can we use the constant-acceleration equations for free fall at all?
Because near Earth's surface is essentially constant, so is constant, which is exactly the condition those kinematic equations were derived under.
Why does a real feather fall slower than a hammer on Earth but not on the Moon?
On Earth air resistance opposes the feather strongly relative to its tiny weight; on the airless Moon that force is gone, so both experience only gravity and fall identically. This is where Air Resistance and Terminal Velocity breaks the ideal.
Why is the acceleration negative (up-positive) even when the ball is momentarily at rest at the top?
Acceleration measures how velocity is changing, not its current value. Even at the instant , the velocity is on its way from to , which is a downward (negative) change — hence .
Why does throwing a ball downward instead of dropping it increase its impact speed but not change its acceleration?
The extra initial speed adds to the final speed through , but the acceleration stays because gravity is unchanged — you altered the starting condition, not the force.
Edge cases
What is the acceleration of an object at the exact instant of release (dropped from rest)?
Already downward. Even though speed is zero at , gravity acts immediately, so the acceleration is from the first instant — it never "ramps up".
If an object is thrown straight up, is there any instant where both velocity AND acceleration are zero?
No. Velocity is zero only at the top, but acceleration is there; there is no moment in ideal free fall where the acceleration vanishes.
What does give when (back to launch height)?
, so . Physically the meaningful root is (downward), confirming the ball returns with launch speed but opposite direction.
For a ball that just barely reaches height with such that it stops exactly there, what is in terms of the drop it then makes?
— the same as the speed a dropped ball gains over that height, since the up-trip and a drop over are mirror images.
At the ground-impact instant of a dropped ball, is the acceleration still ?
Yes, right up to contact the only force is gravity, so . The sudden change happens at impact when the ground exerts a normal force, ending the free-fall phase.
What happens to the free-fall model at very high speeds or long drops in real air?
It fails: air resistance grows with speed until it balances gravity, giving zero net acceleration and a constant terminal velocity. Free fall assumes this force is absent.
If we take down as positive, what is the velocity of a ball thrown upward at the start?
Negative. With down positive, upward motion is the negative direction, so an upward throw begins with while ; the physics matches up-positive after relabeling.
Connections
- Free fall — g = 9.8 m - s², sign conventions (index 1.1.17) — parent topic
- Equations of Motion (constant acceleration)
- Vectors and sign conventions
- Projectile Motion
- Newton's Second Law
- Air Resistance and Terminal Velocity