3.2.4 · D5p-Block

Question bank — Silicon and silicates; silicones; zeolites

1,262 words6 min readBack to topic

True or false — justify

True or false: and have the same structure because they share the formula .
False. is a discrete molecule (strong pπ–pπ double bonds); is a giant covalent solid of Si–O–Si single bridges because large Si has poor sideways 3p overlap and cannot form good double bonds. See Allotropy and giant covalent solids.
True or false: silicon shows stronger catenation than carbon.
False. Si–Si single bonds are weak ( kJ/mol) and easily attacked by water/oxygen, so Si catenates far less than carbon. Silicon prefers strong Si–O chains instead.
True or false: a "silicone" contains no silicon.
False, and it also isn't the element. A silicone is the synthetic polymer — it has an Si–O backbone; the word just distinguishes it from silicon (element), silica () and silicate ().
True or false: sharing more tetrahedron corners raises the negative charge per Si.
False — it lowers it. Each shared (bridging) O is split between two tetrahedra, so it contributes less negative charge; sharing all four corners gives neutral .
True or false: replacing with in a framework leaves the charge unchanged.
False. Al carries one less positive charge than Si, so each substitution makes the framework ; that is exactly why cations sit in the cages. See Ion exchange and water softening.
True or false: zeolites act as catalysts mainly because their loose cations react with substrates.
False. The action is mostly shape-selectivity (pore size lets only certain molecules in/out) plus acidic framework sites — the loose cations are chiefly there for charge balance and exchange.
True or false: the Si–O bond is strong partly because oxygen lone pairs feed into empty Si orbitals.
True. Beyond the ordinary σ bond, O lone-pair density donates into Si's empty 3d orbitals (pπ–dπ), reinforcing it — see Lewis acids and empty d-orbitals. Si–O () beats Si–Si and Si–C.
True or false: quartz melts easily like table salt because both are crystalline.
False. Quartz is a covalent giant network — melting means breaking countless strong Si–O bonds, so it melts very high; ionic melting is a different (and here irrelevant) argument.

Spot the error

A student writes the formula of a single-chain (pyroxene) silicate as . Find the error.
They reused the isolated-unit formula. A chain shares 2 corners, so per Si there are 2 terminal + 2 bridging(½) O = 3 O, giving . Always re-derive from the tetrahedron.
A student explains silicones form because " has three groups so it makes long chains." Fix it.
Backwards. has only one Si–Cl (one reactive site), so it can only cap an end and stop growth. Linear chains come from the dichloride (two reactive sites).
A student says "hydrolysis of gives the polymer directly." Fix it.
Hydrolysis only makes the silanol plus HCl. The polymer forms in the next step: condensation, where two Si–OH lose water to make Si–O–Si. See Condensation polymerisation.
A student claims "asbestos (double chain) has formula like other chains." Fix it.
A double chain shares more corners on average (2.5), so its repeat unit is , not the single-chain . Sharing count sets the formula.
A student writes a zeolite as needing metal cations for AlO groups regardless of metal. Fix it.
Only true for a metal. A metal of charge balances negative sites, so you need of them — e.g. balances two .
A student says "silica is a good electrical conductor because it's a giant structure." Fix it.
Being giant/covalent is unrelated to conduction. All valence electrons are locked in localised Si–O σ bonds (no free/delocalised electrons), so silica is an insulator — unlike graphite.

Why questions

Why does silicon not form a "graphite-like" or "-like" molecular form?
Its large 3p orbitals overlap sideways poorly, so pπ–pπ double bonds are weak; Si satisfies its bonding with strong single Si–O–Si bridges into giant solids instead. Contrast Carbon and its allotropes.
Why is essentially all silicon on Earth found as oxide or silicate, never as free chains of Si?
Si–O ( kJ/mol) is far stronger than Si–Si (), and Si–Si is easily oxidised/hydrolysed, so thermodynamics and kinetics both drive silicon into oxygen-bonded networks.
Why does adding more make a silicone harder and rubbery rather than oily?
has three reactive Si–Cl bonds, so it creates cross-links between chains; more cross-links means a more rigid 3D network — thin oil becomes rubber/resin.
Why does a zeolite need loosely-held cations at all?
Each -for- swap gives the framework charge; the cages must hold exchangeable cations to keep the whole solid neutral.
Why can a zeolite "sieve" molecules by shape?
Its cages and channels have a fixed molecular-scale size, so small molecules pass through while larger ones are excluded — geometry, not chemistry, does the selecting.
Why is Si–O–Si called a bridge that is "neutral," while a corner O of an isolated tetrahedron is not?
A bridging O is shared by two Si and satisfies both its bonds internally; a terminal corner O bonds to only one Si and keeps a negative charge to complete its octet. Trace this in Group 14 trends.

Edge cases

If you share zero corners, what is the smallest silicate unit and its charge?
The isolated tetrahedron: Si + 4 O = . This is the limiting "0 sharing" case (e.g. olivine).
If you share all four corners, why does the charge vanish exactly?
Every O is then split between two Si (counts ½), giving 2 O per Si; , so the framework is neutral — the other limiting extreme.
What silicone does (functionality 4) give, and why is it not a useful oil?
All four sites react and cross-link in every direction, producing a dense rigid 3D network — no flexible chains, so it can't behave as a pourable oil or bendy rubber.
Between the extremes, what does a monomer mix of mostly with a trace of give, and why?
Long linear chains capped short by the occasional end-blocker — a thin, flowing silicone oil; the trace tunes (shortens) the chain length.
At the framework-charge limit, what happens if you substitute so many Si with Al that Al Si?
You break Löwenstein's rule (Al–O–Al bridges become forced), which is energetically disfavoured — real zeolites keep Si/Al , so pure "all-Al" frameworks don't form.

Recall One-line self-test

Cover every answer above, run down the list, and if any reason (not the label) feels shaky, reread the matching parent section before moving on.