2.6.3 · D5Equilibrium

Question bank — Relationship Kp = Kc(RT)^Δn

1,588 words7 min readBack to topic

This bank hunts the ideas behind the parent topic, not the arithmetic. Every prompt below is a place students slip: a sign, a phase, a unit, a limiting case. Read the question, answer out loud, then reveal.


True or false — justify

can only happen when the reaction has no gases at all.
False — it happens whenever ====, i.e. equal moles of gas on both sides (e.g. ), regardless of how many gases are present.
For any reaction, raising temperature makes larger, so always grows relative to .
False — only if . If , larger makes smaller, widening the gap the other way; if the factor stays .
If is dimensionless then must also be dimensionless.
False in the "with units" convention — when the factor carries pressure/volume units, so and generally differ in units. (In strict thermodynamics both are dimensionless via activities.)
The formula works for a reaction in aqueous solution with no gases.
False — it is derived from , which is the ideal gas law. With no gases there are no partial pressures, so is not even defined.
Doubling the container volume changes because pressures drop.
False — (like ) depends only on temperature. Volume changes shift the position of equilibrium (Le Chatelier), not the constant. See Le Chatelier's Principle.
in this formula is the same used everywhere else in the reaction.
False — here counts only gaseous species; a mole balance for stoichiometry or enthalpy may count solids/liquids, but this bridge formula does not.
Because appears in the formula, using a different value of changes the true value of .
False — the number changes only because you changed the units of and . Match to those units and the physical equilibrium is identical.

Spot the error

Student writes: "For , ."
Error: they put reactants − products backwards and miscounted. Products , reactants , so (products − reactants).
Student writes: " with for room temperature."
Error: must be in kelvin. Room temperature is ; the gas law only holds for absolute temperature.
Student writes: "For , ."
Error: solid carbon is not counted. Gaseous products (), gaseous reactants (), so and .
Student writes: ", so pressure is small when is large."
Error: the gas law gives (multiply, not divide). More thermal push means higher pressure for the same crowding. See Ideal Gas Law PV=nRT.
Student writes: "."
Error: is an exponent on , not a multiplier. Correct form is ; the whole is raised to the power .
Student writes: ", and since this makes negative, so ."
Error: a negative exponent gives a reciprocal, not a negative number. ; stays positive (it is a ratio of positive pressures).

Why questions

Why does the ideal gas law, of all tools, bridge and ?
Because it is the one relation linking pressure to amount-per-volume: . Partial pressure is concentration scaled by , so it converts one constant's variables into the other's. See Partial Pressure and Dalton's Law.
Why does the whole conversion collapse to depend only on and nothing else about the reaction?
Every partial pressure contributes one factor of per mole, so the total power of is (product mole powers) − (reactant mole powers) ; all the concentration parts regroup exactly into .
Why is temperature the only thing that changes or , but pressure or volume are not?
is fixed by the reaction's energetics at a given (via , see Gibbs Free Energy and K). Changing or total moves concentrations/partial pressures around until the ratio returns to that same .
Why must "match" the units of and ?
Because must be dimensionally consistent: if is in atm and in mol L⁻¹, then must carry L atm K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ so the units cancel correctly.
Why is defined as products minus reactants and not the reverse?
To mirror the constant itself, which is "products over reactants." With the general reaction , the products sit on top, so their coefficients get the positive sign: .
Why can two reactions with the same have very different ?
Because they can have different . The factor depends on the gas-mole change, so a reaction and a reaction diverge sharply even from identical .

Edge cases

What happens to the formula when ?
, so exactly, for every temperature and every value of — the pressure and concentration pictures coincide.
For , what is and why?
. Only is gaseous; both solids are excluded, so gaseous products , gaseous reactants .
What is for a reaction with no gases (e.g. all-aqueous)?
Undefined — there are no partial pressures to form . The bridge formula simply does not apply; use $K_c$ alone.
At the limiting case (in whatever units), what happens for any ?
, so numerically regardless of — a unit-dependent coincidence, not a physical rule.
If a reaction has and , order and .
is a positive number less than , so — fewer gas moles on the product side pulls the pressure constant below the concentration constant.
What if some reactant is a gas but a product is a pure liquid at that temperature?
Only the gas is counted; the pure liquid contributes to the gas-mole tally (and drops out of entirely), so it lowers the product count in .
Can be a fraction?
Yes, if the balanced equation uses fractional coefficients (e.g. gives ). tracks whatever coefficients you wrote — keep the whole equation consistent.

Recall One-line self-check

If you can state, without the note, (1) which species count in , (2) the sign convention, (3) why the bridge is the ideal gas law, and (4) what happens when — you own this topic.

Connections