2.5.14Thermodynamics (Chemical)

Gibbs free energy ΔG = ΔH − TΔS; spontaneity criteria

1,827 words8 min readdifficulty · medium6 backlinks

1. Deriving ΔG from the Second Law (from scratch)

Step 1 — What is ΔSsurr\Delta S_{surr}? The surroundings act like a giant heat reservoir at constant temperature TT and pressure PP. At constant PP, heat exchanged by the system is qsys=ΔHsysq_{sys} = \Delta H_{sys}.

Why this step? At constant pressure, the heat term equals the enthalpy change — that's literally the definition of enthalpy (qP=ΔHq_P = \Delta H).

The surroundings absorb the opposite heat: qsurr=ΔHsysq_{surr} = -\Delta H_{sys}.

Step 2 — Entropy of surroundings. For a reservoir absorbing heat reversibly: ΔSsurr=qsurrT=ΔHsysT\Delta S_{surr} = \frac{q_{surr}}{T} = \frac{-\Delta H_{sys}}{T}

Why this step? The reservoir is so large its temperature never changes, so the heat flow is effectively reversible for it — meaning ΔS=qrev/T\Delta S = q_{rev}/T applies exactly.

Step 3 — Substitute back. ΔSuniv=ΔSsysΔHsysT\Delta S_{univ} = \Delta S_{sys} - \frac{\Delta H_{sys}}{T}

Step 4 — Multiply by T-T (a positive number, so flip the inequality). TΔSuniv=ΔHsysTΔSsys-T\,\Delta S_{univ} = \Delta H_{sys} - T\,\Delta S_{sys}

We define the right-hand side as the Gibbs free energy change:

Step 5 — Read off the spontaneity criterion. Since T>0T > 0: ΔSuniv>0    ΔG<0\Delta S_{univ} > 0 \iff \Delta G < 0.


2. The four sign combinations (80/20 core table)

The behaviour depends on the signs of ΔH\Delta H and ΔS\Delta S, and sometimes on TT.

ΔH\Delta H ΔS\Delta S ΔG=ΔHTΔS\Delta G = \Delta H - T\Delta S Spontaneous?
− (exo) + always − Always spontaneous
+ (endo) always + Never spontaneous
− (exo) − at low TT Spontaneous only at low TT
+ (endo) + − at high TT Spontaneous only at high TT
Figure — Gibbs free energy ΔG = ΔH − TΔS; spontaneity criteria

3. Worked examples


4. Common mistakes (Steel-man + fix)


5. Flashcards

What thermodynamic quantity determines spontaneity at constant T and P?
The Gibbs free energy change ΔG\Delta G; spontaneous if ΔG<0\Delta G < 0.
Derive the sign relationship between ΔG and ΔS_univ.
ΔG=TΔSuniv\Delta G = -T\Delta S_{univ}, so ΔG<0    ΔSuniv>0\Delta G<0 \iff \Delta S_{univ}>0.
Why does entropy of surroundings equal −ΔH/T?
Surroundings absorb ΔH-\Delta H of heat reversibly at temperature TT, so ΔSsurr=qsurr/T=ΔH/T\Delta S_{surr}=q_{surr}/T=-\Delta H/T.
For ΔH<0, ΔS>0, when is the reaction spontaneous?
Always (at all temperatures), since ΔG\Delta G is always negative.
For ΔH>0, ΔS>0, when spontaneous?
Only at high temperature, when TΔS>ΔHT\Delta S > \Delta H.
At what temperature does an exothermic, entropy-decreasing reaction stop being spontaneous?
When T>ΔH/ΔST > \Delta H/\Delta S (both negative), i.e. above T=ΔH/ΔST=\Delta H/\Delta S.
Does ΔG<0 tell you the reaction is fast?
No — it tells you it's feasible, not the rate; rate depends on activation energy.
Relationship between ΔG° and K?
ΔG=RTlnK\Delta G^\circ = -RT\ln K.
What is ΔG at equilibrium?
Exactly zero.
Full form of ΔG under non-standard conditions?
ΔG=ΔG+RTlnQ\Delta G = \Delta G^\circ + RT\ln Q.

Recall Feynman: explain to a 12-year-old

Nature has two "wants": it likes things to be low energy (like a ball rolling downhill — that's ΔH\Delta H) and it likes things to be messy/spread out (that's ΔS\Delta S). Gibbs energy is a single scoreboard that adds both wants together, with temperature deciding how much "messiness" counts. If the score ΔG\Delta G goes down, the change happens by itself. Hot conditions make messiness count a lot; cold conditions make energy count more. That's the whole story.

Connections

Concept Map

spontaneity rule

surroundings term

constant P heat q = dH

substitute and multiply by -T

by construction

since T > 0

dG < 0

dG = 0

dG > 0

signs of dH and dS

T as tie-breaker

Second Law: dS_univ > 0

dS_univ = dS_sys + dS_surr

dS_surr = -dH/T

q_P = dH

Define dG = dH - TdS

dG = -T dS_univ

Spontaneity: dG < 0

Spontaneous

Equilibrium

Non-spontaneous

Four sign combinations

Crossover at T = dH / dS

Hinglish (regional understanding)

Intuition Hinglish mein samjho

Dekho, Gibbs free energy ka pura funda ek hi line mein hai: ΔG=ΔHTΔS\Delta G = \Delta H - T\Delta S. Yeh actually second law ka hi ek smart repackaging hai. Second law kehta hai ki reaction tabhi khud-ba-khud hoti hai jab universe ki total entropy badhe (ΔSuniv>0\Delta S_{univ}>0). Lekin surroundings ko measure karna mushkil hai, isliye humne surroundings wala part (ΔH/T-\Delta H/T) ko system ke terms mein chhupa diya. Result: sirf beaker dekh kar prediction — agar ΔG\Delta G negative hai to reaction spontaneous hai.

Ismein do "forces" ka tug of war hai. Nature ko low energy pasand hai (enthalpy, ΔH\Delta H) aur disorder/messiness bhi pasand hai (entropy, ΔS\Delta S). Temperature TT decide karta hai ki disorder ko kitna weightage milega. Low temperature pe enthalpy jeetega, high temperature pe entropy jeetega. Isiliye kuch reactions sirf garam karne pe hi chalti hain aur kuch sirf thanda hone pe.

Char cases yaad rakho: ΔH<0,ΔS>0\Delta H<0, \Delta S>0 → hamesha spontaneous; ΔH>0,ΔS<0\Delta H>0, \Delta S<0 → kabhi nahi; baaki do temperature pe depend karte hain, aur crossover temperature T=ΔH/ΔST=\Delta H/\Delta S pe milta hai (jaise ice ka melting point 273 K).

Ek important warning: ΔG<0\Delta G<0 ka matlab reaction "possible" hai, "fast" nahi. Diamond se graphite banna spontaneous hai par crore saal lagte hain — kyunki wo kinetics (activation energy) ka mamla hai, thermodynamics ka nahi. Aur units ka dhyan rakho — ΔS\Delta S J mein hota hai, ΔH\Delta H kJ mein, subtract karne se pehle same unit mein lao warna answer ulta aa jayega.

Go deeper — visual, from zero

Test yourself — Thermodynamics (Chemical)

Connections