2.2.4 · D5Fluid Mechanics

Question bank — Surface tension — origin, Young-Laplace equation

1,187 words5 min readBack to topic

True or false — justify

Surface tension points outward, pushing the bubble open.
False — acts tangentially along the skin, pulling it together (inward-curving). The outward push is the excess pressure the tension forces the gas to supply.
A soap bubble and a water drop of the same radius have the same excess pressure.
False — the drop has one interface (), the soap bubble has two (), so the bubble's excess pressure is double.
A bigger bubble holds more air, so it must be at higher pressure.
False — , so the smaller bubble has the higher internal pressure; more air ≠ more pressure.
A perfectly flat liquid surface has zero pressure jump across it.
True — with , ; only curvature creates the jump.
The units N/m and J/m² describe two different physical quantities.
False — they are dimensionally identical (); force-per-length and energy-per-area are literally the same number .
A molecule in the bulk feels a net inward pull.
False — a bulk molecule has neighbours on all sides, so the cohesive pulls cancel to zero net force; only a surface molecule feels a net inward pull.
Doubling the radius of a water drop halves its excess pressure.
True — is inversely proportional to , so gives .
For a gas cavity (bubble of gas inside a liquid), you use .
False — a gas cavity has a single liquid–gas interface, so ; the "4" is only for a thin soap film with two faces.

Spot the error

"For a soap film on a wire frame, ."
Error: a film has two faces, so and ; dropping the 2 halves your answer.
", so ."
Error: , so ; forgetting the factor from differentiating breaks the whole derivation.
"When two bubbles connect, air flows into the smaller one to inflate it."
Error: the smaller bubble has higher pressure (), so air flows out of it into the larger one — the small shrinks, the big grows.
"Surface tension exists because water molecules repel each other at the surface."
Error: it's the opposite — molecules attract (cohesion); surface molecules simply have fewer neighbours to attract them from above, giving a net inward pull.
"A cylinder of radius has like a sphere."
Error: a cylinder curves in only one direction (), so — half the sphere's value.
"The Young–Laplace law needs both radii equal."
Error: and are independent principal radii; a sphere is just the special case , not a requirement.

Why questions

Why does a free liquid drop take a spherical shape?
A sphere is the minimum surface area for a fixed volume, and minimising area minimises surface energy (), which nature always favours.
Why does curving the surface create a pressure difference at all?
On a curved skin under tension the tension forces have a small inward-pointing component; to keep the surface from collapsing the inside pressure must rise, and that rise is .
Why does a soap bubble carry the factor 4 but a raindrop only 2?
The soap bubble is a thin liquid shell with air on both sides — two interfaces each giving — while the raindrop has a single liquid–air interface.
Why is energy needed to create new surface area?
Moving a molecule from the bulk to the surface breaks some attractive bonds, raising its energy; that energy cost per unit area is exactly .
Why can we equate "work by pressure" to "surface energy cost" in the derivation?
At mechanical equilibrium the surface neither grows nor shrinks spontaneously, so the pressure work pushing out must exactly balance the energy cost of the extra surface created.
Why does smaller radius mean a harder inward squeeze?
Tighter curvature means the tension vectors along the skin tilt more steeply inward, so their net inward component per unit area — hence — is larger.

Edge cases

What is across a completely flat film ()?
Zero — both curvature terms vanish, so no pressure jump exists; this is why still open water has no excess pressure at its top surface.
As a drop shrinks toward , what happens to its excess pressure?
— vanishingly small droplets are at enormous internal pressure, which is why fine mist evaporates and coalesces readily.
What happens to for a saddle-shaped surface where the two curvatures bend opposite ways?
The radii take opposite signs, so can be zero or negative; a soap film on a wire loop settles into exactly such a minimal surface with . See Minimal surfaces & soap films.
If two identical soap bubbles () are joined, which way does air flow?
Neither — equal radii give equal pressures, so the system is in (unstable) balance; any tiny perturbation makes one shrink and the other grow.
What is the pressure jump for a half-cylinder of liquid versus a sphere of the same radius?
The cylinder gives (only one finite curvature) while the sphere gives ; same radius, but the sphere's double curvature doubles the jump.
For a very large flat puddle, why do we usually ignore surface tension pressure but not for a small drop?
Its radius of curvature is effectively infinite, so ; surface-tension pressure only becomes significant when is small (millimetres or less).