1.7.9 · D5Thermodynamics
Question bank — Kinetic theory — pressure derivation, temperature as mean KE
True or false — justify
Every item below is a claim. Decide true/false, then read why.
At the same temperature, hydrogen and xenon molecules have the same average kinetic energy.
True. depends only on , not on mass; same forces the same average translational KE for every ideal gas.
At the same temperature, hydrogen and xenon molecules have the same rms speed.
False. Equal KE with unequal mass means differs — the lighter hydrogen is much faster, since only the product is fixed.
If you double the temperature, the rms speed of the molecules also doubles.
False. , so doubling multiplies rms speed by ; you must quadruple to double the speed.
The rms speed equals the ordinary (arithmetic mean) speed of the molecules.
False. always exceeds because squaring gives extra weight to the fast molecules; they are two genuinely different averages (see Maxwell-Boltzmann Speed Distribution).
For a fixed amount of gas at fixed volume, doubling the absolute temperature doubles the pressure.
True. From with fixed, . Note must be in kelvin — doubling °C does not double .
A heavier gas exerts more pressure than a lighter gas at the same , , and .
False. Pressure is — no mass appears. Heavier molecules hit harder but move proportionally slower, and the two effects cancel exactly.
The factor in the pressure formula is an empirical fudge factor fitted to data.
False. It is the number of spatial dimensions: isotropy gives . In a 2D gas the factor would be ; it is pure geometry.
During a wall collision the molecule does work on the wall and loses kinetic energy.
False. The wall is rigid and stationary and the collision is elastic, so only the direction of flips — the speed, and thus the KE, is unchanged (see Elastic Collisions and Momentum).
The pressure formula assumes molecules never collide with one another.
Partly true and harmless. Intermolecular collisions merely reshuffle velocities among molecules; because they conserve total momentum and energy, the population averages and are untouched, so the derived pressure is the same.
At absolute zero the molecules of an ideal gas would have zero translational kinetic energy.
True within the model. as , so classically all motion stops — real gases liquefy or show quantum effects long before, but the ideal law predicts this limit.
Temperature is a property each individual molecule carries.
False. Temperature is a statistical property of the whole population's average KE. A single molecule has a speed and a KE, but "temperature" only makes sense for the ensemble.
Spot the error
Each statement below contains a mistake. Name it.
"Pressure comes from because pressure is about how fast molecules move on average."
Error: it uses instead of . Momentum transfer per unit time scales with , so pressure depends on the mean of the squares, giving , not .
" because the molecule's momentum before hitting was ."
Error: it forgets the rebound. After an elastic bounce the momentum is , so the change is — the factor of 2 is essential.
"The time between hits on the right wall is , the time to reach the far wall."
Error: it uses a one-way trip. The molecule must travel to the opposite wall and back before hitting the same wall again, so .
", therefore ."
Error: it drops the sum. Since , the three equal parts add: , so .
"Each degree of freedom gets of energy, so 3 directions give per molecule."
Error: each translational degree of freedom carries , not . Three of them give (see Boltzmann Constant and Equipartition).
" using molar mass ."
Error: mixing per-molecule and per-mole quantities. With you must use molecular mass ; with molar mass you must use : .
Why questions
Why does the same "3" appear both as the in the pressure formula and as the in the energy relation?
Both come from the three spatial dimensions. splits the speed among ; equipartition then hands to each of those three directions, giving .
Why can we replace the messy sum of individual forces with ?
Because a sum of squared components equals times their average by definition of the mean: . This is just repackaging, no approximation.
Why does the derivation give a steady pressure when each collision is a sudden isolated kick?
With molecules hitting billions of times per second, the discrete kicks blur into a constant average force — the fluctuations are utterly negligible at everyday scales.
Why does the ideal gas law contain no molecular mass ?
Because and depends only on temperature. The mass cancels since heavier molecules simply move slower to keep the same KE.
Why is (not or the most-probable speed) the natural speed in the pressure derivation?
Because the physics — momentum flux to the wall — is built from , so the average that emerges is , whose square root is by construction. The other averages answer different questions (see Maxwell-Boltzmann Speed Distribution).
Why must we use isotropy (randomness of direction) to finish the derivation?
The pressure on the -wall involves , but energy involves the full . Isotropy lets us swap one for the other via , connecting the wall force to molecular energy.
Why is the mean KE relation about translational KE specifically, not total energy?
The pressure derivation only tracks centre-of-mass motion (). Rotational or vibrational energy exists but pushes on no wall, so it never enters — it does affect heat capacity though (see Degrees of Freedom and Molar Heat Capacity).
Edge cases
What does the model predict for pressure if the container volume shrinks to half at fixed and ?
doubles, since and . Physically, molecules cross the box in half the time, doubling their hit frequency.
What happens to if a gas is compressed while held at constant temperature?
Nothing — depends only on . The molecules hit the walls more often (higher ) but each still carries the same average KE.
In a hypothetical 2-dimensional gas, what replaces the and factors?
With only two directions, , so pressure carries a , and equipartition gives (one per dimension).
If a single molecule happens to move purely along the -axis (), does it contribute to pressure on the -wall?
Not directly — with it never reaches the -wall. But this is one molecule out of ; the population average is what sets the pressure, and it stays .
What does predict as molar mass ?
, so vanishingly light molecules would move arbitrarily fast at fixed — this is why the lightest gases (hydrogen, helium) are the fastest and escape planetary atmospheres most easily.
If temperature is measured in Celsius instead of Kelvin, does still hold?
No. The relation demands absolute temperature; at the KE is not zero (that's of motion). Only Kelvin makes vanish at .
Recall One-line summaries to carry away
- Same ⇒ same KE, different speeds (mass-dependent).
- The and are the 3 spatial dimensions, not fudge factors.
- Pressure uses (so ), never .
- Every temperature in these formulas is Kelvin.
- Elastic wall bounce: only flips, speed and KE unchanged.