1.2.25 · D4Newton's Laws & Dynamics

Exercises — Weightlessness — true (free fall) vs apparent

2,636 words12 min readBack to topic

Throughout, unless told otherwise, take and up as positive.


Level 1 — Recognition

Can you read the situation and pick the right sign of ?

Recall Solution Q1

What we know: at rest means , so . Step — solve for mass. From : . Acceleration: (the scale is not moving nor accelerating). ==, .== The scale reads true weight only when — this is the baseline every later problem departs from.

Recall Solution Q2

The trap-buster: "moving down" is a velocity, and velocity never appears in — only acceleration does. Step — find . Constant velocity ⇒ . Step — apply the law. . == (normal weight — the person feels nothing unusual).==

Recall Solution Q3

Set . Since , we need , i.e. . ==Answer: (c) .== Check the others: (a) (twice as heavy); (b) ; (d) — a negative is impossible for a floor, meaning the person would leave the floor and press on a ceiling instead.


Level 2 — Application

Plug into with the right sign — every quadrant of the sign table.

Recall Solution Q4

Step — sign of . Accelerating up ⇒ . Step — apply. . Step — g-force. True weight . Ratio . ==, i.e. 4 g — the candidate feels four times their weight.==

Recall Solution Q5

Step — direction of . Moving up while slowing ⇒ acceleration points down. Step — apply. . == — lighter than the true .== Notice: same "feel light" outcome as an accelerating-down lift, because slowing an upward rise and speeding a downward drop are the same downward acceleration.

Recall Solution Q6

Step — use the local . The law is with . Step — sign. Accelerating down ⇒ . Step — apply. . ==yes, weightless.== The weightless condition is always , whatever planet you're on. Free fall on the Moon feels identical to free fall on Earth — zero support force either way.


Level 3 — Analysis

Reason backwards, combine ideas, watch the degenerate cases.

Recall Solution Q7

Step — invert the law. . Direction: negative ⇒ acceleration points downward, magnitude . Trick sub-question: No — you cannot tell whether it moves up or down. The scale only reveals , not velocity. It could be accelerating downward while descending, or decelerating while ascending — both give . == downward; direction of motion is undetermined.==

Recall Solution Q8

(a) Free fall ⇒ . . Weightless feeling. (b) This is Free Fall Kinematics: with , (speed grows, take magnitude): . (c) No. True weight the whole time — gravity is fully on; that's exactly why the elevator accelerates at . Only the support force is zero. ==(a) ; (b) ; (c) true weight , not zero.==

Recall Solution Q9

Why centripetal? Standing on a rotating Earth is gentle Circular Motion & Centripetal Acceleration: the person travels a circle once a day, so a tiny net downward acceleration is required. That net force comes from gravity slightly out-pulling the normal force. Step — Newton's 2nd law, down as the acceleration direction. The net downward force must equal : Step — numbers. . Compare: true weight . So the scale reads about less. ==, i.e. below true weight.== This is the same with (downward). Earth's rotation is a mild, permanent "elevator accelerating gently downward."

Figure — Weightlessness — true (free fall) vs apparent

Level 4 — Synthesis

Two ideas at once: orbit, altitude, and free fall together.

Recall Solution Q10

(a) (b) The astronaut and station share the same centripetal acceleration (directed toward Earth). In the station's frame there is nothing left for the floor to supply: More carefully in the ground frame: both need inward, provided entirely by gravity, so the floor contributes nothing. (c) ==They float because astronaut and station free-fall together at ; equal acceleration ⇒ no mutual push ⇒ . Gravity is ~89% of surface, not zero.==

Recall Solution Q11

(a) Here but the floor must accelerate the astronaut at . . (b) They feel a normal push — exactly Earth-surface weight (). With no window, they'd swear they were standing still on Earth. (This is the seed of Non-inertial Frames & Pseudo-forces and Einstein's equivalence principle.) (c) ISS: but free-falling, so gravity present, no support. Deep-space ship: but thrusting, so no gravity, full support. The scale can't distinguish "real gravity" from "acceleration" — it only ever reports . ==(a) ; (b) feels like standing on Earth; (c) opposite causes, and the scale — reporting only — cannot tell them apart.==


Level 5 — Mastery

Design and multi-step reasoning — the whole toolkit at once.

Recall Solution Q12

(a) Weightless ⇒ (the plane must accelerate downward at , i.e. arc over the top of the parabola like a thrown ball). (b) (upward). g-force . (c) No — true weight throughout. Only swings between and . ==(a) ; (b) , ; (c) true weight constant at .==

Recall Solution Q13

Phase (i): . (heavy). Phase (ii): . (normal). Phase (iii): moving up while stopping ⇒ acceleration downward ⇒ . (light). Max speed: reached at end of phase (i): . (Constant through phase (ii), then decelerates to : check ✓, consistent.) ==(i) , (ii) , (iii) ; max speed .==

Figure — Weightlessness — true (free fall) vs apparent
Recall Solution Q14

(a) . . (b) A floor can only push up (); it cannot pull down. The formula's signals the floor has "run out" — the person actually lifts off the floor and, if there's a ceiling, gets pressed against it. The ceiling then supplies a downward on the person (so the ceiling's contact force plays the role, with magnitude ). Without a ceiling, the person floats up relative to the falling lift. == (person leaves floor); the ceiling pushes down with once contact is made.== This is the full picture: isn't "extra-weightless," it's inverted support — the ground stops being the thing that holds you.


Connections