2.3.25Modern Physics

Special relativity — Michelson-Morley experiment

1,975 words9 min readdifficulty · medium6 backlinks

WHY this experiment was done

If the aether is at rest and the Earth orbits the Sun at speed v30 km/sv \approx 30\text{ km/s}, then on Earth we should feel an "aether wind" blowing past us at speed vv. Light moving along the wind vs. across it would then be measurably affected — like a swimmer in a river.


HOW the apparatus works — the interferometer

The Michelson interferometer:

  1. A light beam hits a half-silvered mirror (beam splitter) that splits it into two perpendicular beams.
  2. Each beam travels distance LL to a mirror and reflects back.
  3. The beams recombine and interfere, making bright/dark fringes.
  4. Rotating the apparatus 90°90° swaps which arm is "parallel" to the aether wind — shifting the fringes if the wind exists.
Figure — Special relativity — Michelson-Morley experiment

DERIVATION — from first principles

We compute round-trip times assuming light moves at cc relative to the aether, and the apparatus moves at vv through it.

Parallel arm (along the wind)

t=Lcv+Lc+vt_\parallel = \frac{L}{c-v} + \frac{L}{c+v}

Why this step? Each term is distance ÷\div effective speed for that leg.

Combine over a common denominator: t=L(c+v)+L(cv)(cv)(c+v)=2Lcc2v2=2Lc11v2c2t_\parallel = \frac{L(c+v) + L(c-v)}{(c-v)(c+v)} = \frac{2Lc}{c^2 - v^2} = \frac{2L}{c}\cdot\frac{1}{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}

Perpendicular arm (across the wind)

t=2Lc2v2=2Lc11v2c2t_\perp = \frac{2L}{\sqrt{c^2 - v^2}} = \frac{2L}{c}\cdot\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}}

Why this step? The cross-current effective speed is c2v2\sqrt{c^2-v^2}, used for the full round trip 2L2L.

The predicted time difference

Why expand? β2(104)\beta^2 \approx (10^{-4}) is tiny, so the leading non-zero term β2\propto \beta^2 dominates and gives a clean estimate.

Converting to a fringe shift

Rotating 90°90° swaps the arms, so the change in path difference is c(2Δt)c\cdot(2\Delta t)... more precisely the expected fringe shift is: ΔN=c(2Δt)λ2Lv2λc2\Delta N = \frac{c\,(2\Delta t)}{\lambda} \approx \frac{2L v^2}{\lambda c^2}


The RESULT and its meaning


Common mistakes (Steel-man + fix)


Flashcards

What medium was light thought to need before 1905?
The luminiferous aether.
What did the Michelson–Morley experiment try to detect?
Earth's motion (velocity vv) relative to the aether, via a light-speed difference between arms.
What was the experimental result?
A null result — essentially no fringe shift was observed.
Round-trip time for the parallel arm?
t=2Lc11v2/c2t_\parallel = \dfrac{2L}{c}\dfrac{1}{1-v^2/c^2}
Round-trip time for the perpendicular arm?
t=2Lc11v2/c2t_\perp = \dfrac{2L}{c}\dfrac{1}{\sqrt{1-v^2/c^2}}
Why is the cross-arm light speed c2v2\sqrt{c^2-v^2}?
The beam aims upstream; total speed cc with current vv gives cross-component c2v2\sqrt{c^2-v^2} (Pythagoras).
Leading-order expected time difference?
ΔtLv2c3\Delta t \approx \dfrac{Lv^2}{c^3} (proportional to β2\beta^2).
Why doesn't the parallel arm's fast/slow legs cancel?
You spend more time in the slow (cvc-v) leg, so the round trip is longer than no-wind.
What postulate of SR did the null result support?
The speed of light cc is the same for all observers (constancy of cc).
What classical patch tried to save the aether?
FitzGerald–Lorentz length contraction.
Order of magnitude of β=v/c\beta=v/c for Earth's orbit?
104\sim 10^{-4}, so β2108\beta^2 \sim 10^{-8} — tiny but detectable by the interferometer.

Recall Feynman: explain to a 12-year-old

Imagine two identical swimmers in a flowing river, both swimming the same speed in still water. One swims down the river and back; the other swims straight across and back. Even though they're equally fast, the river current makes their times slightly different. Scientists thought space was filled with an invisible "river" called the aether that light flowed through, and the Earth was zooming through it. They built a machine that raced two light beams — one along the "river," one across it — to catch the time difference. But the beams always tied. No matter how they turned the machine or what time of year, perfect tie. That meant there was no invisible river at all, and light always travels at exactly the same speed for everyone — the idea that launched Einstein's relativity.

Connections

Concept Map

needs medium

Earth moves through it

predicts

tested by

models

beam splitter creates

recombine and interfere

rotate 90 degrees

derived from

measured

refutes

seeds postulate

Light as a wave

Aether hypothesis

Aether wind at v ~ 30 km/s

Direction-dependent light speed

Michelson interferometer

Swimmer-in-river analogy

Two perpendicular beams

Fringe pattern

Expected fringe shift

t parallel vs t perpendicular

Null result — no shift

Speed of light same for all observers

Hinglish (regional understanding)

Intuition Hinglish mein samjho

Bhai socho — 1800s ke scientists maante the ki light ko travel karne ke liye ek invisible medium chahiye, jaise sound ko air chahiye. Us imaginary medium ka naam tha aether. Logic simple tha: Earth sun ke around 30 km/s se ghoom rahi hai, to is aether ke andar Earth move kar rahi hogi, matlab humein ek "aether wind" feel hona chahiye — bilkul jaise chalti car ki khidki se haath bahar nikaalo to hawa lagti hai.

Ab Michelson aur Morley ne ek interferometer banaya. Ek light beam ko beam splitter se do parts mein toda — ek beam wind ke parallel jaata hai aur wapas aata hai, doosra wind ke perpendicular. River-swimmer analogy yaad rakho: current ke saath-against jaane wala swimmer aur across jaane wala swimmer, dono ki speed same hone par bhi time alag lagega. Isi time difference se interference fringes shift honi chahiye thi. Maths se predicted shift tha around 0.40.4 fringes, aur unka machine 0.010.01 fringe tak detect kar sakta tha — to shift saaf dikhna chahiye tha.

Par twist ye hai: kuch bhi shift nahi mila! Chahe machine ko ghumao, chahe saal ke kisi bhi time karo — light dono directions mein exactly same speed se chal rahi thi. Iska matlab: ya to aether hai hi nahi, ya phir light hamesha har observer ke liye same speed cc par chalti hai. Yahi se Einstein ka famous second postulate aaya — speed of light is constant for everyone. Isliye ye "failed" experiment actually physics ka sabse important experiment ban gaya, jisne special relativity ka raasta khola.

Key formula yaad rakho: parallel arm ko 1β21-\beta^2 se divide karo, perpendicular ko 1β2\sqrt{1-\beta^2} se (Pythagoras se c2v2\sqrt{c^2-v^2} aata hai), aur difference Lv2/c3\approx Lv^2/c^3 nikalta hai. Bas isi tiny difference ki talaash thi — jo kabhi mili hi nahi.

Go deeper — visual, from zero

Test yourself — Modern Physics

Connections