2.3.5 · D3Modern Physics

Worked examples — De Broglie hypothesis — matter waves λ = h - p

3,411 words16 min readBack to topic

Before anything, let us pin down every symbol we will lean on, so nothing sneaks in undefined.

We will use exactly four "faces" of the same one formula. Which face you pick depends on what the problem hands you.


The scenario matrix

Every de Broglie problem falls into one of these cells. The rest of the page fills each one.

Cell What's given Which face Watch out for Example
A mass + speed, small particle keep SI units Ex 1
B mass + speed, macroscopic object answer absurdly tiny — that's correct Ex 2
C electron + voltage Å this shortcut is electrons only Ex 3
D kinetic energy (any particle) never use if you only know Ex 4
E temperature (thermal particle) then face D is average, not exact Ex 5
F ratio / comparison, same which quantity is held fixed? Ex 6
G ratio / comparison, same different from cell F! Ex 7
H photon (massless) — degenerate case , is forbidden () Ex 8
I relativistic (speed near light) — limiting case fails, must correct Ex 9
J exam twist: given, find or invert a face algebra runs backward Ex 10

The two "danger cells" are H (mass is zero, so the face literally divides by zero) and I (speed so high that ). We will look those two straight in the eye.


Cell A — small particle, speed given


Cell B — macroscopic object


Cell C — electron accelerated through a voltage


Cell D — kinetic energy given (any particle)


Cell E — thermal particle (temperature given)


Cells F & G — comparisons (this is where students mix things up)

The single most common exam trap: is the energy the same, or the speed the same? The proportionality flips.

Figure — De Broglie hypothesis — matter waves λ = h - p

Cell H — the degenerate case: a massless photon


Cell I — the limiting case: relativistic speed


Cell J — the inverse exam twist


Recall Which face do I use? (self-test)

Given only a temperature, which face and what's the first step? ::: Face D (); first compute . Why can't a photon use ? ::: Its mass is zero, so is undefined; use with . At equal kinetic energy, ? ::: (so electron/proton ratio is ). At equal speed, ? ::: (ratio , not ). When does fail? ::: Near light speed; then with . Given , how do you find the electron voltage? ::: Invert the face: with in Å.


Connections