1.4.3Momentum & Collisions

Conservation of linear momentum — derivation from Newton's third law

1,688 words8 min readdifficulty · medium6 backlinks

WHAT are we proving?

WHY do we care? Because it lets us predict the after of a collision/explosion without knowing the messy details of the forces during contact. We never need to know how the force varied microsecond by microsecond — only the totals before and after.


HOW: derive it from scratch (two-body case)

Take two particles, 1 and 2, that interact only with each other (no outside forces). Particle 2 pushes on 1 with force F12\vec{F}_{12}, and 1 pushes on 2 with F21\vec{F}_{21}.

Step 1 — Newton's 2nd law for each, in momentum form. F12=dp1dt,F21=dp2dt\vec{F}_{12} = \frac{d\vec{p}_1}{dt}, \qquad \vec{F}_{21} = \frac{d\vec{p}_2}{dt} Why this step? Newton's 2nd law is really F=dp/dt\vec F = d\vec p/dt (force = rate of change of momentum). Each particle's momentum changes only because of the force on it.

Step 2 — Newton's 3rd law. F12=F21\vec{F}_{12} = -\vec{F}_{21} Why this step? The forces of an action–reaction pair are equal in magnitude, opposite in direction. This is the engine of the whole proof.

Step 3 — Add the two equations of Step 1. F12+F21=dp1dt+dp2dt=ddt(p1+p2)\vec{F}_{12} + \vec{F}_{21} = \frac{d\vec{p}_1}{dt} + \frac{d\vec{p}_2}{dt} = \frac{d}{dt}\big(\vec{p}_1+\vec{p}_2\big) Why this step? Adding lets the action–reaction pair appear together so we can cancel it.

Step 4 — Use Step 2 on the left side. F12+F21=F12+(F12)=0\vec{F}_{12} + \vec{F}_{21} = \vec{F}_{12} + (-\vec{F}_{12}) = 0

Step 5 — Conclusion. ddt(p1+p2)=0        p1+p2=constant\frac{d}{dt}\big(\vec{p}_1+\vec{p}_2\big) = 0 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; \vec{p}_1+\vec{p}_2 = \text{constant}

Figure — Conservation of linear momentum — derivation from Newton's third law

Generalising to N particles (Forecast-then-Verify)

Total momentum: P=ipi\vec{P}=\sum_i \vec p_i. Differentiate: dPdt=idpidt=iFinet\frac{d\vec P}{dt}=\sum_i \frac{d\vec p_i}{dt}=\sum_i \vec F_i^{\text{net}} Each Finet=jiFijinternal+Fiextexternal\vec F_i^{\text{net}}=\underbrace{\sum_{j\ne i}\vec F_{ij}}_{\text{internal}}+\underbrace{\vec F_i^{\text{ext}}}_{\text{external}}.

Every internal force Fij\vec F_{ij} has a partner Fji=Fij\vec F_{ji}=-\vec F_{ij}, so the double sum of internal forces is zero. Left with: dPdt=iFiext=Fnetext\frac{d\vec P}{dt}=\sum_i \vec F_i^{\text{ext}} = \vec F^{\text{ext}}_{\text{net}}


Worked Examples


Common Mistakes


Active Recall

Recall Why does the

internal force not change total momentum? Because internal forces come in action–reaction pairs (Fij=Fji\vec F_{ij}=-\vec F_{ji}) that cancel exactly when summed over the whole system.

Recall What exact condition makes

P\vec P constant? Net external force on the system is zero.

Recall Where does Newton's 3rd law enter the derivation?

At Step 2/4: it makes F12+F21=0\vec F_{12}+\vec F_{21}=0, so the time-derivative of total momentum vanishes.

Recall Feynman: explain to a 12-year-old

Imagine two kids on skateboards pushing each other. However hard one pushes the other, the other pushes back just as hard the other way. So if one zooms left, the other zooms right by the same "push-amount." Add up both their "motion-money" and it stays the same as before — they only traded it, they didn't make or lose any.



Flashcards

What is linear momentum of a particle?
p=mv\vec p = m\vec v, a vector.
State conservation of linear momentum.
If net external force is zero, total momentum mivi\sum m_i\vec v_i is constant.
Which law makes internal forces cancel?
Newton's third law, Fij=Fji\vec F_{ij}=-\vec F_{ji}.
Newton's 2nd law in momentum form?
F=dp/dt\vec F = d\vec p/dt.
Master equation linking total momentum and external force?
dP/dt=Fnetextd\vec P/dt = \vec F^{\text{ext}}_{\text{net}}.
In an inelastic collision, what is conserved and what isn't?
Momentum is conserved; kinetic energy is not.
Gun recoil: bullet 0.01 kg at 400 m/s, gun 2 kg — recoil speed?
2 m/s opposite to bullet.
Why conserve momentum component-wise in 2D?
Momentum is a vector; each axis conserves independently.

Connections

Concept Map

applied to each

applied to each

summed

summed

makes

with 3rd law

gives

derivative zero means

proves

required for

generalises to

causes

only external changes P

Newton 2nd law F = dp/dt

Newton 3rd law F12 = -F21

dp1/dt = F12

dp2/dt = F21

Add equations

Forces cancel to zero

d/dt of p1+p2 = 0

p1+p2 = constant

Conservation of momentum

Isolated system no external force

N-particle case

Internal forces cancel in pairs

Hinglish (regional understanding)

Intuition Hinglish mein samjho

Dekho, idea bilkul simple hai. Newton ka teesra niyam kehta hai ki jab do cheezein ek dusre ko dhakka deti hain, toh dono barabar force lagati hain par opposite direction me — F12=F21\vec F_{12} = -\vec F_{21}. Ab momentum ka matlab hai p=mv\vec p = m\vec v, aur force actually momentum ke change ka rate hai, yaani F=dp/dt\vec F = d\vec p/dt. Toh dono particles ke equations ko jod do, action-reaction pair zero ho jaata hai, aur bachta hai ddt(p1+p2)=0\frac{d}{dt}(\vec p_1 + \vec p_2) = 0. Jab kisi cheez ka time-derivative zero ho, matlab woh constant hai. Bas, momentum conserve!

Yeh kyon important hai? Kyunki collision ke andar force kaise badalta hai — woh details bahut messy hote hain. Lekin total momentum hume bina un details ke before/after ka relation de deta hai. Gun firing, rocket, carom board, cricket ball bat se takraana — sab me yahi kaam aata hai.

Ek baat dhyan rakhna: momentum tabhi conserve hota hai jab external force zero ho (isolated system). Friction ya wall ka push external hai, woh momentum badal sakta hai. Aur ek aur trap: inelastic collision me momentum toh bachta hai par kinetic energy nahi bachti (heat/sound me chali jaati hai). Direction yaad rakhna — momentum vector hai, plus-minus sign hi asli physics hai (recoil ka minus dekho Example 1 me).

Go deeper — visual, from zero

Test yourself — Momentum & Collisions

Connections