3.1.19Advanced Trigonometry

Law of sines — proof and applications (ambiguous case)

1,961 words9 min readdifficulty · medium1 backlinks

WHAT is the Law of Sines?

The key term to cloze: the common ratio equals ==2R2R== (the circumdiameter).


WHY is it true? — Derivation from scratch

Step 1 — Drop an altitude (the core idea)

Take triangle ABCABC. Drop a perpendicular of height hh from vertex CC onto side ABAB.

Why this step? An altitude splits the triangle into two right triangles, and in a right triangle sin(angle)=oppositehypotenuse\sin(\text{angle}) = \frac{\text{opposite}}{\text{hypotenuse}} — that's the only trig fact we need.

In the right triangle on the left, angle AA has opposite side hh and hypotenuse bb: sinA=hb    h=bsinA\sin A = \frac{h}{b} \implies h = b\sin A

In the right triangle on the right, angle BB has opposite side hh and hypotenuse aa: sinB=ha    h=asinB\sin B = \frac{h}{a} \implies h = a\sin B

Why this step? Both expressions equal the same height hh, so we can equate them.

bsinA=asinB    asinA=bsinBb\sin A = a\sin B \implies \frac{a}{\sin A} = \frac{b}{\sin B}

Repeat with an altitude from AA onto BCBC to get bsinB=csinC\dfrac{b}{\sin B} = \dfrac{c}{\sin C}. Done for the ratio equality.

Step 2 — WHY the ratio is 2R2R (the circumcircle part)

Draw the circumcircle of radius RR. Draw diameter BDBD through vertex BB (so DD is on the circle, BD=2RBD = 2R).

  • Angle BCD=90°\angle BCD = 90° (angle in a semicircle is a right angle).
  • Angles A\angle A and D\angle D subtend the same chord BCBC, so by the inscribed-angle theorem D=A\angle D = \angle A.

In right triangle BCDBCD: sinD=BCBD=a2R\sin D = \frac{BC}{BD} = \frac{a}{2R}

Since sinD=sinA\sin D = \sin A: sinA=a2R    asinA=2R\sin A = \frac{a}{2R} \implies \frac{a}{\sin A} = 2R

Why this step? It upgrades a mere "equal ratios" statement into a geometric constant: the ratio literally measures the circle the triangle lives on.

Figure — Law of sines — proof and applications (ambiguous case)

HOW do we use it? (When to reach for it)

Use the Law of Sines when you know:

  • AAS / ASA — two angles and one side → find the rest (unique, safe).
  • SSA — two sides and an angle not between them → ambiguous case ⚠️.

The ambiguous case, decoded (assume AA acute, given a,b,Aa, b, A)

Compute sinB=bsinAa\sin B = \dfrac{b\sin A}{a}. The critical length is the altitude h=bsinAh = b\sin A.

Condition Number of triangles
a<h=bsinAa < h = b\sin A 0 (side too short to reach base)
a=ha = h 1 (right triangle, just touches)
h<a<bh < a < b 2 (arc cuts base twice: BB and 180°B180°-B)
aba \ge b 1 (long side, only one valid BB)

Why the "180°B180° - B" second solution? Because sinB=sin(180°B)\sin B = \sin(180° - B), the equation for BB can have two answers in (0°,180°)(0°,180°). Keep the second one only if A+(180°B)<180°A + (180° - B) < 180°, i.e. the angles still fit in a triangle.


Worked examples


Recall Explain it to a 12-year-old (Feynman)

Imagine a triangle drawn perfectly inside a circle. The Law of Sines says: take any side, divide it by the "sine" of the corner facing it — you always get the same number, and that number is exactly how wide the whole circle is (its diameter). The tricky "ambiguous" part: suppose I tell you one corner's angle and two stick lengths, but not exactly how they connect. It's like swinging a door hinge — sometimes the door tip hits the wall in two spots, sometimes in one, sometimes it can't reach at all. So there can be two different triangles, one, or none!


Common mistakes


Active-recall flashcards

#flashcards/maths

What does the common ratio asinA\frac{a}{\sin A} equal geometrically?
The circumdiameter 2R2R (twice the circumcircle radius).
State the Law of Sines.
asinA=bsinB=csinC=2R\frac{a}{\sin A}=\frac{b}{\sin B}=\frac{c}{\sin C}=2R.
In the proof, why does h=bsinAh=b\sin A also hold when AA is obtuse?
Because sin(180°A)=sinA\sin(180°-A)=\sin A, so the altitude relation is unchanged.
Which triangle-inference cases use Law of Sines?
AAS, ASA (unique) and SSA (ambiguous).
Which theorem gives the 2R2R part of the proof?
The inscribed-angle theorem plus "angle in a semicircle is 90°90°".
Given a,b,Aa,b,A (A acute), what is the critical altitude length?
h=bsinAh=b\sin A.
When does SSA give exactly two triangles?
When h<a<bh<a<b (i.e. bsinA<a<bb\sin A < a < b).
When does SSA give no triangle?
When a<bsinAa<b\sin A, equivalently sinB>1\sin B>1.
When does SSA give exactly one triangle (medium/long)?
When a=bsinAa=b\sin A (right angle, tangent) or aba\ge b.
Why is there sometimes a second solution 180°B180°-B?
Because sinB=sin(180°B)\sin B=\sin(180°-B); keep it only if A+(180°B)<180°A+(180°-B)<180°.
Which law should you use for SAS or SSS instead?
The Law of Cosines.

Connections

  • Law of Cosines — the go-to for SAS/SSS; complements Sines for SSA.
  • Inscribed Angle Theorem — powers the 2R2R result.
  • Circumcircle and Circumradius R — the geometric meaning of the ratio.
  • Sine of Supplementary Anglessin(180°θ)=sinθ\sin(180°-\theta)=\sin\theta, root of the ambiguity.
  • Area of a TriangleArea=abc4R\text{Area}=\frac{abc}{4R} links directly to RR here.
  • Solving Oblique Triangles — decision flowchart AAS/ASA/SSA/SAS/SSS.

Concept Map

states

equals

links to

gives

use sin = opp/hyp

foot falls outside

keeps valid

angle in semicircle

inscribed-angle theorem

applies to

applies to

leads to

Law of Sines

a/sinA = b/sinB = c/sinC

2R circumdiameter

Circumscribed circle

Drop an altitude h

Two right triangles

Obtuse angle A

sin 180-A = sin A

Diameter BD

Right angle BCD

AAS / ASA unique

SSA case

Ambiguous case

Hinglish (regional understanding)

Intuition Hinglish mein samjho

Dekho, Law of Sines ka core idea bahut simple hai: kisi bhi triangle mein, jo side jitni badi hoti hai uska saamne wala angle bhi utna hi bada hota hai. Formula bolta hai asinA=bsinB=csinC\frac{a}{\sin A}=\frac{b}{\sin B}=\frac{c}{\sin C} — yaani side ko uske opposite angle ke sine se divide karo, teeno ke liye same number aayega. Aur mazedaar baat: yeh number exactly 2R2R hai, jahan RR triangle ke bahar wale circle (circumcircle) ka radius hai. Proof mein hum altitude hh girate hain, do right triangles bante hain, aur dono se hh nikaal ke equate kar dete hain — bas ho gaya.

Ab asli twist hai ambiguous case (SSA). Jab tumhe do sides aur ek angle diya ho jo un dono ke beech mein nahi hai, tab problem hoti hai. Socho ek side ko darwaze ki tarah hinge se ghuma rahe ho — kabhi woh base line ko do jagah touch karti hai (do triangle), kabhi ek jagah, kabhi pahunchti hi nahi (koi triangle nahi). Critical length hai h=bsinAh=b\sin A. Agar a<ha<h toh triangle banega hi nahi, agar h<a<bh<a<b toh do triangle banenge.

Do triangle kyun? Kyunki sinB=sin(180°B)\sin B = \sin(180°-B) — matlab BB ke do possible values ho sakte hain. Isliye jab bhi SSA problem aaye, calculator se mila BB lo, phir 180°B180°-B bhi check karo, aur dekho ki angle sum 180°180° se kam rehta hai ya nahi. Yeh cheez exams mein bahut marks kha jaati hai, toh hamesha dono solutions verify karo. Agar sinB>1\sin B>1 aa jaye, matlab triangle possible hi nahi — seedha "no solution" likh do.

Go deeper — visual, from zero

Test yourself — Advanced Trigonometry

Connections