3.1.6 · D5Advanced Trigonometry

Question bank — Graphs of sin x, cos x, tan x — key features, period, amplitude

1,483 words7 min readBack to topic

True or false — justify

Every statement below is either true or false. Decide, then give the reason.

can equal for some large
False — is a coordinate on a radius- circle, so it can never leave no matter how large grows; the wave just repeats, it never climbs higher.
and are never equal for any
False — they are equal wherever the point sits on the diagonal , e.g. at where both equal ; see Exact Values of Trig Ratios.
The period of is smaller than the period of
True — repeats every while repeats every , because the two sign-flips at cancel in the ratio .
has amplitude because it is a trig function
False — near each asymptote races off to , so it has no maximum or minimum; amplitude only exists for a bounded up-and-down swing.
is just slid to the right by
False in direction — cosine leads sine (it peaks a quarter-turn earlier), so , a slide to the left.
but
True — reflecting the angle across the horizontal axis flips the -coordinate (sine, odd) but leaves the -coordinate (cosine, even) untouched.
Every zero of is also a place where
True — is zero exactly when its top is zero and its bottom ; at cosine is , so all these are genuine zeros.
Every zero of is a zero of
False — where we are dividing by zero, so has an asymptote there, the opposite of a zero.
The graph of is continuous everywhere
False — it breaks at every where cosine vanishes; between consecutive asymptotes it is one unbroken branch, but the asymptotes chop it into separate pieces.

Spot the error

Each line states a claim with faulty reasoning; the reveal names the flaw.

" has period ."
Error — a bigger makes the wave faster, so you divide: period . Ask "how much must grow so the inside grows by ?"
" has period ."
Error — 's base period is , not , so the period is ; using double-counts because the ratio already repeats after half a turn.
" has amplitude when the cosine dips negative."
Error — amplitude is a size, always ; the going negative is already built into the range, not a change of amplitude.
" has no solutions because a wave never touches a line."
Error — crosses the axis every half-period, at ; a smooth wave crosses zero, it does not avoid it.
"The midline of is ."
Error — the lifts the whole wave, so the midline is ; the wave then swings between and . See Transformations of Graphs.
" starts at like ."
Error — at the point is at the right , so (a crest) while ; cosine crests, sine starts at sea-level.
"To find the period of you must know ."
Error — only slides the graph sideways (phase shift), it never changes how often it repeats; period depends on alone, .
" can be made to have amplitude by writing ."
Error — multiplying by stretches the curve vertically but it still shoots to ; a function with no bound cannot acquire an amplitude.

Why questions

Answer with the mechanism, not just the fact.

Why is the range of and exactly ?
Because both are coordinates of a point pinned to a circle of radius ; a coordinate can be at most the radius in size, so it lives between and .
Why does have period and not ?
Moving half a turn () flips the point to the opposite side, negating both and ; in the ratio the two minus signs cancel, so it repeats after only .
Why does blow up to infinity at certain points?
At the point is at the top or bottom of the circle, so its horizontal coordinate is ; dividing by that zero drives off to .
Why does increasing in shrink the period?
The inside reaches sooner when is bigger, so one full cycle is completed after a smaller change in : period .
Why is even but odd?
Negating the angle reflects the point across the horizontal axis; the horizontal position () is unchanged (even) while the height () flips sign (odd).
Why can we solve by solving ?
A fraction is zero only when its numerator is zero, so needs — provided so we are not at an asymptote. See Solving Trigonometric Equations.
Why do sine and cosine graphs describe a swinging pendulum or spring?
Their smooth, bounded, repeating up-and-down is exactly the motion of an object oscillating about a rest point, which is why and model Simple Harmonic Motion.
Why does the identity warn you where misbehaves?
Reading it as a ratio makes the danger visible: wherever the denominator hits zero, the whole expression is undefined; the identity is from Trigonometric Identities.

Edge cases

The scenarios that break naive rules.

What is at ?
It is undefined, so the ratio divides by zero; the graph has an asymptote, not a value, there.
Does take the value and the value at the same places?
No — zeros happen where (at ) and asymptotes where (at ); these two sets never overlap, they alternate.
What is the amplitude of ?
Zero — the wave is flattened onto the line ; it is a degenerate constant function, technically periodic but with no swing at all.
What happens to the period of as ?
The period grows without bound, so the wave stretches flatter and flatter; in the limit it becomes the constant with no repeating at all.
At exactly which points do and momentarily agree in value on ?
At (both ) and (both ), the two crossing points of their graphs.
Is the largest value of on the open interval ever reached?
No maximum exists — as from below, increases without bound; it approaches but never attains a top value.

Connections

#flashcards/maths