Intuition What this page is
The parent note built the four rules. Here we stress-test them against every kind of input you can meet: positives, negatives, mixed numbers, zero, whole numbers in disguise, decimals, and word problems. If a case exists, there's a worked example below that hits it.
Before a single symbol: recall that a fraction b a means "cut a whole into b equal pieces, take a of them." The top number a is the numerator (how many pieces), the bottom b is the denominator (size of each piece). A negative fraction like − 5 3 means "owe" three of those fifths, or "sit three-fifths to the left of zero" on a number line. Look at the figure below and keep that number-line picture in mind — it saves you on every sign question.
On the line above, 0 sits in the middle. Positive fractions live to the right ; negative fractions live to the left . Adding a positive means stepping right; adding a negative (or subtracting a positive) means stepping left.
Definition The "golden rule" (our nickname)
Throughout this page, "the golden rule" is our shorthand for the fact that multiplying the numerator and denominator by the same nonzero number does not change a fraction's value :
b a = b ⋅ k a ⋅ k ( k = 0 ) .
Reason: cutting each piece into k smaller pieces gives k times as many pieces, each k times smaller — the total amount is unchanged. This one fact powers common denominators and cancelling.
Every fraction problem lands in one of these cells . The worked examples that follow are each tagged with the cell they cover, so together they fill the whole grid.
Cell
What makes it tricky
Example
A — Add/subtract, both positive
need a common denominator
Ex 1
B — Subtraction giving a negative
order matters, sign of the answer
Ex 2
B2 — Subtracting a negative (a − ( − b ) )
two minuses become a plus
Ex 2b
C — Mixed numbers
convert to improper first
Ex 3
D — Multiply, one negative
different signs → negative
Ex 4
D2 — Multiply, two negatives
same signs → positive
Ex 4b
E — Zero as an input
0 times / plus / divided
Ex 5
F — Whole number in disguise
write n = 1 n
Ex 6
G — Division, answer >1 and <1
"how many fit?" both directions
Ex 7
H — Divide by a whole number (limiting)
flip the whole number
Ex 8
I — Real-world word problem
choose the right operation
Ex 9
J — Exam twist (order of operations, decimals)
BODMAS + decimal↔fraction
Ex 10
Two sign rules we'll lean on (from the number line, not memory):
Same signs → positive; different signs → negative for × and ÷ .
Subtracting d c is the same as adding − d c ; and subtracting a negative is adding a positive.
Worked example Ex 1 · Compute
8 3 + 12 5
Forecast: guess — will the answer be more or less than 1 ? (Both parts are less than a half, so under 1 .)
Find the LCM of 8 and 12 : it's 24 .
Why this step? We can only add equal-size pieces. The LCM is the smallest denominator both fit into, so the numbers stay small.
Rewrite using the golden rule (defined above — multiply top and bottom by the same number): 8 3 = 8 ⋅ 3 3 ⋅ 3 = 24 9 , and 12 5 = 12 ⋅ 2 5 ⋅ 2 = 24 10 .
Why this step? Multiplying top and bottom by the same number never changes the value — it just re-cuts the pizza into equal slices.
Add numerators: 24 9 + 10 = 24 19 .
Why this step? Same-size pieces now — just count them.
Verify: 24 19 ≈ 0.79 < 1 ✓ (matched the forecast). Also 24 9 < 24 10 so the 12 5 part is the bigger chunk — sensible.
Worked example Ex 2 · Compute
4 1 − 3 2
Forecast: we're taking a bigger thing (3 2 ) away from a smaller thing (4 1 ). So the answer should be negative — left of zero on the number line.
Rewrite subtraction as adding a negative: 4 1 + ( − 3 2 ) .
Why this step? Keeps the sign explicit so we don't lose it.
Common denominator = 12 : 4 1 = 12 3 , 3 2 = 12 8 .
Why this step? Equal pieces before combining.
Subtract numerators keeping order: 12 3 − 8 = 12 − 5 = − 12 5 .
Why this step? 3 − 8 = − 5 — the negative appears naturally because we removed more than we had.
Verify: flip the question: 3 2 − 4 1 = 12 8 − 3 = 12 5 . So 4 1 − 3 2 must be its negative, − 12 5 ✓. On the number line 4 1 = 0.25 , subtract 0.66 … lands at − 0.41 6 = − 12 5 ✓.
Common mistake Order flips the sign
b a − d c and d c − b a are negatives of each other, never equal. Whenever the second fraction is bigger, expect a minus.
Worked example Ex 2b · Compute
6 1 − ( − 4 3 )
Forecast: we are removing a debt — two minuses. Removing something negative makes you richer , so the answer should be bigger than 6 1 , and positive.
Turn "subtract a negative" into "add a positive": 6 1 − ( − 4 3 ) = 6 1 + 4 3 .
Why this step? Two minus signs cancel: taking away an owed amount is the same as gaining it. On the number line, subtracting a leftward jump means jumping right .
Common denominator = 12 : 6 1 = 12 2 , 4 3 = 12 9 .
Why this step? Equal pieces before adding.
Add numerators: 12 2 + 9 = 12 11 .
Verify: 12 11 ≈ 0.917 > 6 1 ≈ 0.167 ✓ — bigger and positive, exactly as forecast. Sanity check the double-minus: − ( − 4 3 ) = + 4 3 , and 6 1 + 4 3 is clearly under 1 ✓.
Worked example Ex 3 · Compute
2 2 1 + 1 4 3
Forecast: roughly 2.5 + 1.75 = 4.25 , so expect about 4 4 1 .
Convert each mixed number to an improper fraction : 2 2 1 = 2 2 ⋅ 2 + 1 = 2 5 and 1 4 3 = 4 1 ⋅ 4 + 3 = 4 7 .
Why this step? A mixed number is secretly a whole plus a fraction; turning it into one fraction lets us use the standard rule.
Common denominator = 4 : 2 5 = 4 10 .
Why this step? Equal pieces.
Add: 4 10 + 4 7 = 4 17 .
Convert back: 17 ÷ 4 = 4 remainder 1 , so 4 17 = 4 4 1 .
Why this step? Answers are usually reported as mixed numbers when bigger than 1 .
Verify: 4 4 1 = 4.25 , matching the forecast exactly ✓.
Worked example Ex 4 · Compute
− 10 9 × 6 5
Forecast: different signs → answer is negative . Both factors have size under 1 -ish, so the size shrinks below 10 9 .
Sign first: one negative, one positive → the result is negative . Work with sizes, restore the sign at the end.
Why this step? Handling the sign separately stops silly errors.
Cancel before multiplying, showing every factor. Write each top and bottom in factored form:
10 9 × 6 5 = 2 ⋅ 5 3 ⋅ 3 × 2 ⋅ 3 5 .
The factor 5 on top cancels the 5 on the bottom; one factor 3 on top cancels the 3 on the bottom:
2 ⋅ 5 3 ⋅ 3 × 2 ⋅ 3 5 = 2 3 × 2 1 .
Why this step? Cancelling is the golden rule (bk ak = b a ) applied early — factoring first makes the shared numbers obvious, so we shrink big numbers before multiplying.
Multiply straight across: 2 3 × 2 1 = 4 3 .
Restore the sign: − 4 3 .
Verify: without cancelling, 10 ⋅ 6 9 ⋅ 5 = 60 45 = 4 3 ✓, and the sign is negative → − 4 3 ✓.
Worked example Ex 4b · Compute
( − 7 4 ) × ( − 8 7 )
Forecast: same signs (both negative) → the product must be positive . Guess the size: a bit over 2 1 .
Sign first: negative × negative = positive .
Why this step? Taking the opposite of an opposite lands you back on the positive side — "the enemy of my enemy is my friend." Handle the sign now, then just work with sizes.
Cancel with explicit factoring: 7 4 × 8 7 = 7 4 × 4 ⋅ 2 7 . The 7 on top cancels the 7 on the bottom, and the 4 on top cancels the factor 4 on the bottom:
7 4 × 4 ⋅ 2 7 = 1 1 × 2 1 = 2 1 .
Why this step? Golden rule again — cancel shared factors before multiplying.
Attach the sign from step 1: the answer is + 2 1 .
Verify: without cancelling, 7 ⋅ 8 4 ⋅ 7 = 56 28 = 2 1 ✓, and negative × negative gives + 2 1 ✓ — positive, just over "a bit," matching the forecast.
Worked example Ex 5 · Compute (a)
0 × 9 7 , (b) 5 2 + 0 , (c) 0 ÷ 5 2 , (d) 5 2 ÷ 0
Forecast: three of these are easy; one is a trap .
(a) 0 × 9 7 = 1 ⋅ 9 0 ⋅ 7 = 9 0 = 0 .
Why? Zero of anything is nothing.
(b) 5 2 + 0 = 5 2 .
Why? Adding "no extra pieces" changes nothing — 0 is the additive identity.
(c) 0 ÷ 5 2 = 0 × 2 5 = 2 0 = 0 .
Why? "How many 5 2 -chunks fit inside nothing?" None.
(d) 5 2 ÷ 0 = undefined .
Why? This asks "how many chunks of size 0 fit into 5 2 ?" — no number of zeros ever builds up 5 2 . Division by zero is not allowed.
Verify: parts (a)(b)(c) give 0 , 5 2 , 0 ; part (d) has no value. Reason: a fraction's denominator can never be zero — every fraction b a requires b = 0 , because you cannot cut a whole into "zero equal pieces." Flipping-and-multiplying would need the reciprocal of 0 , which doesn't exist, so the operation is genuinely undefined ✓.
Worked example Ex 6 · Compute
3 − 7 4
Forecast: just under 3 , since we take away a little over half of one.
Write the whole number as a fraction: 3 = 1 3 .
Why this step? Every whole number is "itself over 1 ." Now both are fractions and the rule applies.
Common denominator = 7 : 1 3 = 7 21 .
Why this step? Equal pieces before subtracting.
Subtract: 7 21 − 7 4 = 7 17 = 2 7 3 .
Verify: 2 7 3 ≈ 2.43 , and 3 − 0.57 = 2.43 ✓ — just under 3 as forecast.
Worked example Ex 7 · Compute (a)
6 5 ÷ 3 1 and (b) 3 1 ÷ 6 5
Forecast: (a) asks "how many thirds fit in 6 5 ?" — more than one, so >1 . (b) is the reverse — a big thing into a small one — so <1 .
(a) Flip the divisor and multiply: 6 5 × 1 3 .
Why this step? The reciprocal 1 3 turns 3 1 into 1 , undoing the multiply.
Cancel 3 with 6 : 2 5 × 1 = 2 5 = 2 2 1 .
(b) Flip the divisor: 3 1 × 5 6 .
Cancel 3 with 6 : 1 1 × 5 2 = 5 2 .
Verify: (a) and (b) should be reciprocals of each other, and indeed 2 5 × 5 2 = 1 ✓. 2 5 = 2.5 > 1 ✓, 5 2 = 0.4 < 1 ✓ — both forecasts met.
Worked example Ex 8 · Compute
7 6 ÷ 4
Forecast: sharing 7 6 among 4 people → each gets much less than 7 6 .
Write the whole number as a fraction: 4 = 1 4 .
Why this step? We need a fraction to flip.
Flip the divisor: 7 6 × 4 1 .
Why this step? Reciprocal of 1 4 is 4 1 — dividing by 4 is the same as taking a quarter.
Cancel 2 from 6 and 4 : 7 3 × 2 1 = 14 3 .
Verify: 14 3 ≈ 0.214 , and 7 6 ÷ 4 = 0.857/4 ≈ 0.214 ✓ — much smaller than 7 6 , as forecast.
Worked example Ex 9 · A recipe needs
4 3 cup of sugar per batch. You have 2 9 cups of sugar. How many full batches can you make?
Forecast: this is a "how many fit?" question → division . 2 9 = 4.5 cups, each batch eats 0.75 cup, so around 6 batches.
Identify the operation: "how many 4 3 -cup chunks are in 2 9 cups?" = 2 9 ÷ 4 3 .
Why this step? Division literally answers "how many of these fit into that."
Flip the divisor: 2 9 × 3 4 .
Cancel 3 from 9 , and 2 from 4 : 1 3 × 1 2 = 6 .
Why this step? Cancelling keeps arithmetic clean.
Interpret: 6 full batches (exact, no leftover here).
Verify: 6 batches × 4 3 cup = 6 × 4 3 = 4 18 = 2 9 cups — uses exactly all the sugar ✓. Units: (cups) ÷ (cups/batch) = batches ✓.
Worked example Ex 10 · Compute
3 2 + 4 1 × 0.6
Forecast: multiplication happens before addition (BODMAS), and 4 1 × 0.6 is small, so the answer is a bit over 3 2 .
Turn the decimal into a fraction: 0.6 = 10 6 = 5 3 .
Why this step? Fractions and decimals are the same numbers; fractions keep the arithmetic exact.
Do the multiplication first: 4 1 × 5 3 = 20 3 .
Why this step? Order of operations — × before + .
Now add: 3 2 + 20 3 . LCM( 3 , 20 ) = 60 : 3 2 = 60 40 , 20 3 = 60 9 .
Why this step? Equal pieces before adding.
Add numerators: 60 40 + 9 = 60 49 .
Verify: 60 49 ≈ 0.817 . Decimal route: 4 1 × 0.6 = 0.15 , then 0.6 6 + 0.15 = 0.816 6 ✓ — just over 3 2 as forecast.
Recall Which cell, and what's the first move?
A) 7 5 − 7 6 ::: Cell B (negative subtraction). Same denominator already → 7 5 − 6 = − 7 1 .
B) 8 3 ÷ 6 ::: Cell H. Write 6 = 1 6 , flip → 8 3 × 6 1 = 16 1 .
C) 0 ÷ 9 4 ::: Cell E. Equals 0 .
D) 9 4 ÷ 0 ::: Cell E trap. Undefined .
E) ( − 5 2 ) × ( − 4 5 ) ::: Cell D2. Same signs → positive; = 2 1 .
F) 3 1 − ( − 6 1 ) ::: Cell B2. Two minuses → add; = 2 1 .
Mnemonic The safety checks
Sign: different signs in × ÷ → negative; same signs → positive .
Two minuses: a − ( − b ) = a + b — subtracting a debt makes you richer.
Size sense: × by < 1 shrinks; ÷ by < 1 grows.
Zero: 0 ÷ anything = 0 , but anything ÷ 0 is undefined (denominators must be nonzero).