4.1.1 · D5General Organic Chemistry (GOC)

Question bank — Tetravalency of carbon; hybridization recap (sp, sp², sp³)

2,140 words10 min readBack to topic

First, the vocabulary these traps use

Before you gamble on any trap, make sure you own these four ideas. Each is defined here from zero so you never have to hunt.


True or false — justify

True or false: A carbon forming a double bond is always .
False as stated — it is only if that C has exactly 3 σ bonds. The central C in O=C=O forms two double bonds yet is , because it has only 2 σ bonds. Count σ, not double bonds.
True or false: More π bonds on an atom means more hybrid orbitals.
False — the opposite. π bonds use unhybridized p orbitals, so more π bonds means fewer hybrid orbitals ( has 2 hybrids and 2 leftover p; has 4 hybrids and 0 leftover p — exactly the trend drawn in s02).
True or false: Promotion of the electron proves carbon "wants" four bonds.
False — carbon has no desires. Promotion costs energy, but that cost is repaid by the two extra bonds formed afterward. It happens purely because the refund exceeds the bill, not out of "want."
True or false: All four C–H bonds in methane are identical.
True — that identity is the reason hybridization must exist. One + three unequal orbitals mix into four equivalent hybrids, so every bond has the same length (109 pm) and strength.
True or false: An carbon is more electronegative than an carbon of the same element.
True has 50% s-character vs 25% for . More s-character holds shared electrons closer to the nucleus, so the carbon pulls electron density harder.
True or false: A lone pair on the central atom raises the steric number just like a σ bond does.
True — recall . In methanol's oxygen, 2 σ + 2 lone pairs gives SN 4 → , even though O forms only two bonds.
True or false: Bond length follows .
True — higher s-character shortens bonds: . This is a consequence of s-character, not a memorized list.
True or false: Hybridization can occur between orbitals of very different energies.
False — only orbitals of nearly equal energy on the same atom mix. That is why mixes with but not, say, with .

Spot the error

Find the flaw: "Ethyne has a triple bond, so each carbon is ."
The triple bond is 1 σ + 2 π (see the head-on/sideways split in s01). Each carbon has only 2 σ bonds (one C–H, one C–C) and 0 lone pairs → SN 2 → ====, linear . The "3" of was mistakenly read off the "triple."
Find the flaw: "In CO₂ the oxygen lone pairs make carbon's SN larger, so C is ."
Only lone pairs on the central atom count. The oxygens' lone pairs are irrelevant to carbon. Carbon has 2 σ + 0 lone pairs → SN 2 → ====, linear (O=C=O).
Find the flaw: "Carbon is divalent because it has four valence electrons but two are paired in , and pairs never bond."
The pairing observation is right for the ground state (), but the conclusion is wrong: promotion unpairs the electron into , giving four unpaired electrons and true tetravalency.
Find the flaw: "The C=C π bond is what fixes the angle in ethene."
The angle comes from the three hybrid orbitals (the head-on σ framework) spreading as far apart as possible in a plane. The π bond is the sideways overlap sitting perpendicular above and below — it locks planarity but does not set the angle. Compare the σ vs π geometry in s01.
Find the flaw: "Since benzene has alternating double bonds, its carbons switch between and ."
Every ring carbon has 3 σ bonds (2 ring C–C, 1 C–H) + 0 lone pairs → all are ====. The leftover p orbitals (one per carbon, the grey lobe in s02's panel) overlap into a single delocalized π system.
Find the flaw: "Promotion makes carbon less stable because it costs energy."
Promotion alone costs energy, but you must account for the whole process: the two additional bonds formed afterward release far more energy, so the final molecule is much more stable. Never judge an intermediate step in isolation.

Why questions

Why do we count σ bonds and lone pairs — but not π bonds — in the steric number?
A hybrid orbital is needed for each σ bond and each lone pair (they define the directional skeleton). π bonds form from pure unhybridized p orbitals that lie sideways on top of that skeleton (the orange lobes in s01), so they never demand their own hybrid.
Why does more s-character make a bond shorter and stronger?
An orbital is spherical and centred right on the nucleus, so more s-character keeps the bonding electrons closer to the positive nucleus — a tighter, shorter, stronger bond.
Why is the terminal alkyne C–H acidic while an alkane C–H is not?
The carbon (50% s-character) holds the C–H electron pair very close to the nucleus, so when the H⁺ leaves, the resulting negative charge on carbon is well-stabilized. That stability makes losing H⁺ favourable.
Why must the number of hybrid orbitals equal the number of atomic orbitals mixed?
Each orbital is a mathematical wavefunction, and hybrids are just weighted sums of the originals; you cannot build more independent sum-functions than you started with, nor fewer without discarding one. So atomic wavefunctions produce exactly hybrid wavefunctions (), same as input vectors spanning an -dimensional space.
Why is the H–O–H-type angle in methanol's oxygen slightly less than ?
Oxygen is (SN 4) but two of the four positions are lone pairs. A lone pair is held by only one nucleus, so its cloud is fatter and spreads out more than a bonding pair (which is pinched between two nuclei); it therefore pushes the two bonding orbitals closer, dropping the angle below the ideal tetrahedral value.
Why can't a molecule rotate freely about a C=C double bond but can about a C–C single bond?
The double bond includes a π bond from sideways p-orbital overlap (the orange lobes in s01); twisting by would slide the lobes apart and break the bond. A single bond is only σ (end-on, cylindrically symmetric), so rotation leaves the overlap unchanged and costs almost nothing.

Edge cases

Edge case: What is the hybridization of the central carbon in allene, ?
The central carbon has 2 σ bonds + 0 lone pairs → SN 2 → ====. Its two π bonds use two perpendicular p orbitals, forcing the two end CH₂ groups into perpendicular planes. The two end carbons are .
Edge case: A carbene has one lone pair and 2 σ bonds — what SN and hybridization?
SN = 2 σ + 1 lone pair = 3 → ==== (bent, angle < ). This shows the divalent carbon of the ground state can still hybridize once you count its lone pair.
Edge case: A carbon radical like the methyl radical has one lone single electron — what SN?
The single unpaired electron sits in one orbital, so it counts like a lone pair: SN = 3 σ + 1 = 4 → nominally , but the shallow energy cost makes it nearly ==planar == with the odd electron in a p orbital. It hovers between the two, which is why radicals are floppy and easily flipped.
Edge case: A carbon cation like the methyl cation has an empty orbital — what hybridization?
The carbon has 3 σ bonds + 0 lone pairs (the "missing" electrons leave an empty orbital, which is not counted) → SN 3 → ====, trigonal planar, with the empty orbital being the leftover unhybridized p perpendicular to the plane. Contrast this with the carbanion below.
Edge case: Does a carbon with a formal negative charge (carbanion, e.g. ) count that extra electron pair?
Yes — the carbanion has 3 σ bonds + 1 lone pair → SN 4 → , pyramidal. The extra filled pair behaves exactly like any lone pair in the count (unlike the cation's empty orbital, which does not).
Edge case: For a resonance system like the allyl cation, is each carbon a fixed hybridization?
All three carbons are throughout; the "moving" π electrons are delocalized over the unhybridized p orbitals, but the σ skeleton and hybridization stay fixed.
Edge case: Nitrogen in (hydrogen cyanide) — what hybridization?
The N has 1 σ bond (to C) + 1 lone pair = SN 2 → ====, and it carries two π bonds through its two leftover p orbitals. Same logic as carbon, applied to nitrogen.
Edge case: Can hybridization ever be or for carbon?
No — carbon's valence shell (n=2) has no orbitals, so it maxes out at (SN 4). Expanded octets requiring orbitals appear only from period 3 onward.

Recall One-line survival rule

Count σ bonds + lone pairs on the atom → that number is 2, 3, or 4 → , , or . An empty orbital (cation) is not counted; a filled lone pair or a single radical electron is. Everything else — angle, length, acidity, electronegativity — follows from s-character.