2.1.19 · D1 · Physics › Analytical Mechanics › Principle of least action — Hamilton's principle derivation
Un tamam kalpaniy raston mein se jo ek system fixed start aur fixed finish ke beech le sakta hai, nature woh akela rasta chunti hai jahan ek running total — action — path ki kisi bhi choti si nudge ke neeche change karna band kar deta hai. Yeh sentence symbols mein padhne ke liye bhi pehle aapko "function", "derivative", "integral", aur "ek number jo poora function khata hai" ki boli samajhni hogi; yeh page un sabhi ko zero se build karta hai.
Yeh page parent derivation ke liye toolbox hai. Yahan kuch bhi assumed nahi hai — hum zero se bhi neeche shuru karte hain.
Socho ek moti (bead) ek taar (wire) par fisal rahi hai. Har pal woh kahin na kahin hoti hai. Agar taar seedha track hai toh woh "kahin" ek akela number hai.
t aur coordinate q
t (saral shabd: time ) clock ki reading hai. Picture: ek stopwatch par number jo sirf aage badhta hai.
q (ek generalized coordinate ) hai "system abhi kahan hai", ek number mein sama hua. Taar par moti ke liye, q taar ke saath doori hai. Pendulum ke liye, q jhoolne ka angle ho sakta hai.
"Generalized" kyun? Taaki wahi machinery kaam kare chahe natural label length ho, angle ho, ya kuch bhi aur. Topic ko EK symbol chahiye jiska matlab "state" ho, setup se parwah na ho.
Upar neele curve ko dekho: horizontal axis time t hai, vertical axis position q hai. Ek dot matlab "moti us pal kahan hai". Saare dots ko jodon aur aapko ek path milta hai.
q ( t )
Function ek machine hai: usse time t do, woh us time par position q wapas deta hai. Hum ise q ( t ) likhte hain, padho "q of t".
Picture: upar figure mein poori neeli curve — moti ki complete history, sirf ek pal nahi.
Intuition Ek hi letter q pahnne wali do alag cheezein
Function q (ya "q ( ⋅ ) ") poora path hai — poori neeli curve.
Value q ( t ) woh akela number hai jo path ek instant t par return karta hai — curve par ek dot.
Inhe alag rakho: variations poore path par kaam karte hain, jabki energies instantaneous value se compute hoti hain.
Intuition Parent "poore path" par kyun itna focus karta hai
Newton motion ko pal-pal describe karta hai (abhi force → abhi acceleration). Hamilton's principle poori curve ko ek saath judge karta hai. Isliye jo fundamental object hum manipulate karte hain woh poora function q hai, na ki ek akela number. Yeh baat yaad rakho — yahi poora plot twist hai.
Related deeper ideas Newton's Second Law aur Lagrangian Mechanics mein hain.
Moti sirf kahin nahi hai; woh chal rahi hai. Kitni tez?
Definition Dot ka matlab hai "time mein change ki rate"
q ˙ (padho "q-dot") velocity hai: q har second kitna tezi se badalta hai. Yeh q ka t ke saath derivative hai, likha jata hai d t d q .
Picture: ek point par neeli curve ki tadhad (slope) . Steep curve = tez chal rahi hai; flat curve = pal bhar ke liye ruki hui hai.
Intuition Derivative kyun aur sirf difference kyun nahi?
Hume instantaneous speed chahiye — bilkul time t par slope, kisi chunk ka average nahi. Derivative bilkul wahi sawaal ka jawab deta hai: "agar main curve mein itna zoom karoon ki woh seedhi lage, uska slope kya hai?" Yahi woh cheez hai jo calculus limit deliver karta hai.
Narangi line tangent hai — uska slope us pal hai q ˙ . Yeh slope woh ingredient hai jise baad ki energies use karti hain; yeh "position curve ka slope" se zyada kuch nahi.
Definition Partial derivative
∂ / ∂ ( ⋅ )
Partial derivative ∂ x ∂ f poochta hai: "agar main sirf x ko nudge karoon aur baaki sab input frozen rakhoon, toh f kitna tezi se badlega?" Teda ∂ (bolo "partial") ka matlab hai "ek input hilta hai, baaki sab still rehte hain". Picture: ek pahadi surface par khade ho aur sirf seedhe east mein kadam rakhna — partial woh slope hai jo aapko us ek direction mein mehsoos hota hai.
q ˙ ek alag independent variable hai q se."
Yeh sahi kyun lagta hai: 2 1 m q ˙ 2 − V ( q ) jaise formula mein hum q aur q ˙ ko alag slots ki tarah treat karte hain jab partial derivatives lete hain (ek nudge karo, doosra freeze karo).
Theek karna: kisi given path ke liye, q ˙ poori tarah q se determined hota hai (yeh slope hai). Woh sirf "independent" ki tarah kaam karte hain jab us formula ke partial derivatives lete hain — yeh ek bookkeeping trick hai, physics nahi.
Definition Kinetic energy
T
T = motion ki energy. Mass m ke liye jo speed q ˙ se chal raha hai,
T = 2 1 m q ˙ 2 .
Picture: jab curve steep ho (tez) tab badi hoti hai. Hamesha ≥ 0 kyunki yeh q ˙ 2 use karta hai (square kabhi negative nahi hota). m mass hai — "kitna stuff hai", kitna mushkil hai dhakka dena.
Definition Potential energy
V
V = position ki stored energy — woh energy jo aapko milti agar system gir/relax ho jaata. Depend karta hai aap kahan hain: V = V ( q ) .
Picture: pahadi par unchai. Upar = bada V ; ghati ka nichla hissa = chhota V .
Intuition Topic ko DONO alag-alag kyun chahiye
Action inhe T − V (kinetic minus potential) ki tarah combine karta hai. Newton ki force V ke andar chhipi hai: force pahadi ki slope ka minus hai, F = − d q d V . T aur V ko alag rakhna hi aakhir mein parent ko F = ma recover karne deta hai.
Hari ghati V ( q ) hai; lal arrow force ko downhill dikhata hai, yaani chhote V ki taraf. Woh akeli picture hai jis se F = − d V / d q aata hai.
Minus kyun, plus kyun nahi?
Yeh parent ki central non-obvious choice hai. Justification guess nahi hai — T − V ko machinery mein daalo toh Newton wapas milta hai, jabki T + V nahi milta. Socho "kinetic credit minus potential debt": path dono ke beech negotiate karta hai.
∫ t 1 t 2 ( ⋯ ) d t
Lamba-S symbol ∫ ka matlab hai "continuously jodte jao" . ∫ t 1 t 2 L d t yatra ko chhoti-chhoti time slices d t mein kaata hai, har ek ko us instant par L se multiply karta hai, aur shuru ke time t 1 se end time t 2 tak sab jodta hai.
Picture: L -vs-t curve ke neeche ka area .
Intuition Integral kyun, plain sum kyun nahi?
Time smoothly behta hai, isliye hume infinitely many infinitely-thin slices chahiye. Integral bilkul "woh sum hai jo continuous ho gaya hai". Yeh jawab deta hai: "poori journey mein total accumulated L kya hai?"
Shaded area integral hai. Path q ( t ) badlo aur L ( t ) badlega, toh area bhi badlega — woh badalta area hi action hai.
S [ q ]
S [ q ] = ∫ t 1 t 2 L d t .
Functional ek machine hai jo ek poora function q khata hai aur ek number (ek area) return karta hai. Square brackets S [ q ] signal karte hain "main poora function leta hoon, sirf ek value nahi".
Picture: koi bhi neeli curve chuno → ek number milta hai (uska shaded area). Alag curve → alag number.
Intuition Ordinary function vs functional
Function q ( t ) : number in → number out.
Functional S [ q ] : poori curve in → number out.
Parent ka poora khel yahi hai: tamam curves mein se, kaunsi woh output number ko stationary banati hai?
η ( t ) aur knob ε
Yeh test karne ke liye ki "kya yeh path khaas hai?", ise nudge karo:
q ε ( t ) = q ( t ) + ε η ( t ) .
η ( t ) (Greek "eta") ek wiggle-shape hai jo hum freely chun sakte hain. Yeh continuously differentiable (C 1 : isme koi jumps aur koi sharp corners nahi hain, isliye uski slope η ˙ exist karti hai aur khud bhi continuous hai) hona chahiye. Yeh smoothness hi baad mein ise differentiate karne aur integration by parts karne deti hai.
ε (Greek "epsilon") ek chhota volume knob hai wiggle kitna bada ho uske liye.
Endpoints pinned rehte hain: η ( t 1 ) = η ( t 2 ) = 0 (start aur finish fixed data hain).
δ S = 0 — "stationary"
δ S woh first-order change hai S mein jab aap knob ε thoda sa ghumate ho. δ S = 0 kehna matlab hai: path ko thoda sa nudge karna first order mein action ko nahi badlata .
Picture: ghati ka sabse nichla hissa — wahan flat hai, isliye ek chhota kadam side mein aapki unchai nahi badlata (first order mein).
Neeli curve sahi path hai; dashed narangi curves wiggled versions q + ε η hain, dono lal endpoints par pin ki gayi hain. Daaya panel S ko knob ε ke function ki tarah dikhata hai: sahi path par (ε = 0 ) curve flat hai — woh flatness hi δ S = 0 hai .
path is a function q of t
instantaneous value q at time t
derivative q-dot the slope
Lagrangian L equals T minus V
integral adds L over the trip
vary the path with eta and epsilon
stationary delta S equals zero
Hamilton principle derivation
Related destinations jab yeh tools mil jayein: Hamiltonian Mechanics , Noether's Theorem , Fermat's Principle , Feynman Path Integral .
Function q (path) ka matlab poori curve hai ya ek akeli value? Poori curve — time ke saath complete history.
Value q ( t ) ka matlab poori curve hai ya ek akela number? Ek akela number — ek instant t par position.
Derivative q ˙ ki kya picture hai? Ek instant par position-vs-time curve ki slope (tadhad).
Partial derivative ∂ f / ∂ x kya measure karta hai? f ki change ki rate jab sirf x nudge hota hai aur baaki sab inputs frozen rehte hain.
T = 2 1 m q ˙ 2 hamesha ≥ 0 kyun hai?Kyunki q ˙ 2 ek square hai, aur squares kabhi negative nahi hote.
Ek line mein, V ke terms mein force kya hai? Potential ki slope ka minus, F = − d V / d q (downhill point karta hai).
L barabar T + V hai ya T − V ?T − V — woh combination jo Newton ko reproduce karta hai.
Integral ∫ L d t ki picture kya hai? Trip ke dauran L -versus-t curve ke neeche ka area.
Functional, function se kaise alag hai? Functional poora function khata hai aur ek number return karta hai; function ek number khata hai.
Wiggle η mein kitni smoothness honi chahiye, aur kyun? C 1 (continuous with a continuous derivative), taaki uski slope exist kare aur integration by parts kaam kare.
η ko endpoints par kya satisfy karna chahiye aur kyun?η ( t 1 ) = η ( t 2 ) = 0 , kyunki endpoints fixed data hain aur hil nahi sakte.
δ S = 0 geometrically kya matlab rakhta hai?Action chhoti path nudges ke neeche flat (stationary) hai — jaise ghati ka sabse nichla hissa.
Kya "stationary" minimum guarantee karta hai? Nahi — yeh minimum, maximum, ya saddle kuch bhi ho sakta hai.