4.2.5 · D1Hydrocarbons

Foundations — Markovnikov vs anti-Markovnikov (peroxide effect, Kharasch)

1,732 words8 min readBack to topic

Before you can understand Markovnikov vs anti-Markovnikov (not just memorise it), you need a small toolbox of pictures. This page builds every one of them from zero — no symbol is used before it is drawn.


1. What a line between two atoms means (the bond)

Figure — Markovnikov vs anti-Markovnikov (peroxide effect, Kharasch)

Look at the figure: the two grey balls are carbon nuclei, and the blue cloud between them is the pair of shared electrons. That cloud is what the line stands for.


2. The double bond and the symbol

A double bond () is two lines, meaning two shared pairs. But the two pairs are not identical twins.

Figure — Markovnikov vs anti-Markovnikov (peroxide effect, Kharasch)

In the figure the green pair hugs the axis; the yellow pair floats in two lobes above and below.


3. "Unsymmetrical" — why sides differ

If both the alkene and the reagent were symmetrical, there would be only one possible product and no rule to learn. The entire Markovnikov question exists only because both are lopsided, so the two landing choices give different molecules.


4. Counting hydrogens, and ""

The whole rule is phrased "H adds to the carbon with more H's." So we must be able to count H's on a carbon and rank carbons.

Figure — Markovnikov vs anti-Markovnikov (peroxide effect, Kharasch)

5. Charge and the lone electron: and

The topic runs through two different half-finished species. You must be able to read both symbols.

Figure — Markovnikov vs anti-Markovnikov (peroxide effect, Kharasch)

6. The half-arrows and full arrows

You don't need to draw these yet, but when the parent note shows electrons "grabbing" or bonds "snapping homolytically," full vs half arrows are the bookkeeping.


7. Homolysis and bond strength (why only HBr)


8. Exothermic vs endothermic (why chains live or die)


Prerequisite map

Bond = shared electron pair

Pi cloud = loose exposed pair

Homolysis = split one each

Pi grabbed by attacker

Degree 1 2 3 of carbon

Stability ranking

Intermediate forms

Carbocation plus

Radical dot

Bond strength numbers

Exothermic or not

Only HBr chain survives

Markovnikov vs anti-Markovnikov


Equipment checklist

A single line drawn between two atoms physically represents what?
One shared pair of electrons (a covalent bond).
In a double bond, what is the difference between the sigma and pi pairs?
Sigma sits tightly on the axis between the carbons; pi is a looser, exposed cloud above and below — and pi is the reactive one.
What does "unsymmetrical" mean for an alkene or reagent, and why does it matter here?
The two ends are not mirror images, so the two landing choices give different products — which is the whole reason a rule is needed.
How do you decide if a carbon is 1°, 2°, or 3°?
Count how many other carbons are directly attached (one, two, three).
What is the symbol and meaning of a carbocation?
— a carbon missing an electron pair, positively charged, electron-hungry.
What is the symbol and meaning of a free radical?
— a neutral carbon holding one unpaired lonely electron.
What is homolysis?
Breaking a bond so each atom keeps one electron, producing two radicals.
What does a weak bond dissociation energy tell you?
The bond snaps easily with little energy — like the O–O bond of peroxide (~150 kJ/mol).
What is the difference between an exothermic and endothermic step?
Exothermic releases energy (downhill, easy); endothermic absorbs energy (uphill, reluctant).
Why must you know exothermic vs endothermic to explain "only HBr"?
A radical chain survives only if both repeating steps are exothermic; HBr's are, HCl's and HI's are not.

Connections

  • Parent topic
  • Alkenes - Addition Reactions
  • Carbocation Stability and Hyperconjugation
  • Free Radical Mechanisms
  • Bond Dissociation Energies
  • Electrophilic Addition of HX
  • Hydroboration-Oxidation