2.5.5 · D5Thermodynamics (Chemical)
Question bank — Enthalpy H = U + PV; ΔH for reactions at constant P
This is a rapid-fire trap deck for the parent enthalpy topic. Cover the answer, say your reasoning out loud, then reveal. If your reason is wrong but your yes/no is right, you still got it wrong — the reasoning is the point.
True or false — justify
always (the magnitude of always exceeds the magnitude of ), therefore always
False — the first clause holds when (then ), but the conclusion is a non-sequitur: what compares and is their difference , whose sign is set by whether gas moles rise or fall, so can be greater than, less than, or equal to .
holds for any reaction
False — it holds only at constant pressure (that is what the subscript on demands); at constant volume the heat is instead, because no expansion work is done.
An exothermic reaction always has
True — "exothermic" is defined as heat leaving the system, and is measured from the system's viewpoint, so it must be negative.
If the beaker feels hot, the reaction is endothermic
False — a hot beaker means the surroundings gained heat, so the system lost it; that is exothermic, .
For a reaction with only solids and liquids,
True — condensed phases barely change volume, so and the two energy changes nearly coincide.
is a state function, so depends on the path taken
False — being a state function is exactly the reason depends only on initial and final states, which is what makes Hess's Law work.
and are the same number for every reaction
False — is pinned to standard conditions (1 bar, 298 K, 1 M); at other conditions can differ.
A bomb calorimeter measures directly
False — a bomb is rigid (constant volume), so it measures ; you must add (assuming ideal gas, constant ) to reach .
Spot the error
", and since the gas expanded, , so the system does negative work."
Error: with , expansion means volume increases, so ; then , meaning the system loses energy doing positive work on the surroundings.
", and we count all species, so for , "
Error: only gaseous moles count in (the formula rests on , which applies to the gas phase), so here .
"Since and this reaction releases heat, both and must be negative."
Error: the sign of depends on ; a strongly negative could in principle leave with a different magnitude or sign, so you cannot assert its sign without computing.
" because energy is conserved."
Error: conservation makes them equal and opposite, ; heat leaving one enters the other.
"For , gas moles increase, so the system does expansion work."
Error: moles go from , a decrease, so ; the surroundings compress the system, and work is done on it (), not by it.
" means the reaction is spontaneous."
Error: spontaneity is decided by (see Entropy and Gibs Free Energy), not by alone; entropy and temperature also matter.
"Standard enthalpy of formation of is some tabulated positive value."
Error: the standard formation enthalpy of an element in its reference form is zero by definition (see Standard Enthalpy of Formation).
Why questions
Why do chemists prefer over for lab thermochemistry?
Because most reactions run in open vessels at constant atmospheric pressure, where the measured heat is directly, sparing you from tracking expansion work separately.
Why does the term appear as and not ?
Track the differentials (recall = exact, = path-dependent, from the intuition box above). The First Law reads , and for work , so . Differentiating the definition gives , so at constant () we get , i.e. . The was chosen precisely so the term cancels; would give at constant , doubling the work instead of cancelling it.
Why is often less negative than for a gas-shrinking reaction?
When gas moles fall, and the surroundings do work on the system (); part of 's drop is that inward push, so comes out closer to zero.
Why can Bond Enthalpies give only an estimate of a reaction's ?
Bond enthalpies are averages over many molecules and ignore phase changes and the contribution, so they approximate rather than reproduce the exact .
Why does ignore liquids and solids?
Because it comes from , which is a gas law. Quantitatively, one mole of ideal gas at 298 K, 1 bar occupies about 24.8 L, whereas one mole of liquid water is only ~0.018 L — over a thousand times smaller — so the condensed-phase change is negligible next to the gas term (see PV Work and Expansion and the size comparison in Figure 1).
Why must we specify "per mole of reaction as written" for ?
Because scales with how the equation is balanced; doubling the coefficients doubles , so the value is meaningless without its stoichiometry.
Edge cases
What is for a reaction where , like ?
Then , so exactly — the enthalpy and internal-energy changes are identical.
What happens to the rule for a reaction run at constant volume?
It breaks; with no work is done, so the measured heat is , and you recover afterward via the calorimetry correction (ideal gas, constant ).
If a reaction has but a large entropy increase, can it still be spontaneous?
Yes — at high enough the term outweighs the positive , making ; this is why decomposes only when strongly heated.
At , what does the correction become?
It vanishes, since , so regardless of how many gas moles change — the temperature factor switches off the work term.
If a reaction's temperature swings significantly while it proceeds, is still safe to use?
No — that shortcut assumes a single constant ; when changes appreciably the product shifts for all gas moles (not just ), so you must evaluate at the actual initial and final states rather than plug in one .
For a phase change like melting ice at constant pressure, what does equal?
It equals the heat absorbed at constant , i.e. — the latent heat of fusion — because melting is a constant-pressure process where even though no chemical bonds break.
Can and ever have opposite signs?
In principle yes, if is large enough to flip the sum's sign; in practice for most reactions is small (a few kJ), so they usually share a sign.
Recall One-line self-test
Cover everything above and answer: " under what single condition, and what does the P in literally stand for?" Constant pressure; the P labels that the pressure is held fixed, which is the only condition under which enthalpy change equals measured heat.