Periodic Table — First Look
Level 3 (Production) — From-Scratch Reasoning & Explain-Out-Loud
Time limit: 45 minutes
Total marks: 50
Instructions: Answer all questions. Where asked to "explain from scratch," write your reasoning as if teaching a peer. Symbols and configurations must be reproduced from memory.
Q1. (10 marks) Mendeleev arranged elements by increasing atomic mass, yet the modern table uses atomic number. (a) State Mendeleev's periodic law. (2) (b) Explain from scratch why atomic mass ordering produced anomalies (e.g., Ar–K, Co–Ni, Te–I). Give ONE specific mass-vs-number pair and show numerically why swapping is needed. (4) (c) State the Modern Periodic Law and explain how atomic number resolves the anomaly you chose. (4)
Q2. (8 marks) From memory, write the symbols for the first 30 elements in order (H … Zn). For any THREE symbols that are not simply the first letter(s) of the English name, explain the origin of the symbol. (8) (6 marks for a fully correct symbol list; 2 marks for the three explanations.)
Q3. (10 marks) Derive, from electron-configuration reasoning alone (no lookup of block labels), which block each of the following belongs to. Show the configuration and state the block: (a) Element (2) (b) Element (2) (c) Element (3) (d) Explain the general rule connecting the last-filled subshell to the block name. (3)
Q4. (8 marks) Given only the atomic number : (a) Build the electron configuration from scratch. (2) (b) Determine its period and group number, showing your reasoning (do not quote a memorised position). (4) (c) Predict whether it is a metal, non-metal, or metalloid, and justify using two periodic-trend arguments. (2)
Q5. (8 marks) Explain-out-loud: A student claims "metalloids are just weak metals." (a) Define metal, non-metal, and metalloid using at least three distinguishing physical/chemical properties each (tabulate). (6) (b) Name two metalloids from the first 30 elements and rebut the student's claim in one sentence. (2)
Q6. (6 marks) Reasoning task: Two elements X and Y have atomic numbers 11 and 12. (a) Predict which has the larger atomic radius and explain from first principles (nuclear charge vs shells). (3) (b) Predict which is the more reactive metal and justify. (3)
Answer keyMark scheme & solutions
Q1 (10)
(a) Mendeleev's Law: "The properties of elements are a periodic function of their atomic masses." (2)
(b) Ordering strictly by mass sometimes placed an element in a group whose properties didn't match. Chosen pair — Ar and K:
- Atomic mass Ar ≈ 39.95, K ≈ 39.10. By mass, K (39.10) < Ar (39.95), so mass-ordering would put K before Ar. (2)
- But Ar is a noble gas (Group 18) and K is a reactive alkali metal (Group 1); putting K before Ar wrecks the group pattern. So Mendeleev had to swap them against mass order. (2) (Accept Co(58.93)–Ni(58.69) or Te(127.6)–I(126.9) with correct numbers.)
(c) Modern Periodic Law: "Properties of elements are a periodic function of their atomic numbers." (2)
- By atomic number: Ar , K . So Ar naturally comes before K — the swap Mendeleev forced by hand is automatic and correct with -ordering; anomaly vanishes. (2)
Q2 (8)
Correct list (6 marks, deduct pro-rata; ~0.2/element): H, He, Li, Be, B, C, N, O, F, Ne, Na, Mg, Al, Si, P, S, Cl, Ar, K, Ca, Sc, Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn.
Non-obvious symbols (any THREE, 2 marks):
- Na (sodium) — from Latin natrium.
- K (potassium) — from Latin kalium.
- Fe (iron) — from Latin ferrum.
- Cu (copper) — from Latin cuprum. (He/Ne etc. are fine as first letters; award for genuinely Latin-derived ones.)
Q3 (10)
(a) : . Last-filled = → p-block. (2)
(b) : . Last-filled = → s-block. (2)
(c) : . Last (differentiating) electron = → d-block. (3) (1 for config total = 26, 1 for identifying 3d filling, 1 for block.)
(d) Rule: the block is named after the subshell that receives the last (differentiating) electron: s-filling → s-block, p-filling → p-block, d-filling → d-block, f-filling → f-block. (3)
Q4 (8)
(a) (P): . (2)
(b) (4)
- Period = highest principal quantum number present = 3 (the ). (2)
- Group: p-block group number = . Valence electrons ⇒ group Group 15. (2)
(c) Non-metal. (2) Justification (any two): high electronegativity/ionisation energy in upper-right region; tends to gain/share electrons (forms /covalent oxides); poor electrical conductor; located on non-metal side of the metalloid staircase.
Q5 (8)
(a) Table (6 marks, ~0.67 per correct property cell, min 3 each):
| Property | Metal | Non-metal | Metalloid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conductivity | Good (electrical/thermal) | Poor (insulator) | Intermediate/semiconductor |
| Lustre | Lustrous | Dull | Often lustrous |
| Malleability | Malleable, ductile | Brittle (if solid) | Brittle |
| Electron behaviour | Lose electrons (electropositive) | Gain electrons (electronegative) | Can do either |
| Oxide nature | Basic | Acidic | Amphoteric |
(b) Two metalloids in first 30: B (Z=5) and Si (Z=14). (1) Rebuttal: metalloids are not weak metals — they are a distinct category with semiconductor behaviour and amphoteric oxides, properties intermediate between metals and non-metals, not merely a lesser degree of metallic character. (1)
Q6 (6)
(a) X = Na (), Y = Mg (); both Period 3. Na has larger radius. (3) Reasoning: same shell (n=3), but Mg has one more proton (+12 vs +11) with no extra shell, so greater effective nuclear charge pulls the electron cloud inward ⇒ radius decreases left→right; Na (fewer protons) is larger.
(b) Na is more reactive (as a metal). (3) Reasoning: metallic reactivity ∝ ease of losing electron(s); Na loses one electron with lower ionisation energy (larger radius, less nuclear pull), whereas Mg holds its two electrons more tightly ⇒ Na ionises more readily and is more reactive.
[
{"claim":"Ar(Z=18) precedes K(Z=19) by atomic number, fixing the mass anomaly","code":"Ar_Z=18; K_Z=19; result = Ar_Z < K_Z"},
{"claim":"Z=15 valence electrons = 5, giving group 15 (10+5)","code":"valence=2+3; group=10+valence; result = group==15"},
{"claim":"Z=26 electron count sums to 26 for 1s2 2s2 2p6 3s2 3p6 4s2 3d6","code":"total=2+2+6+2+6+2+6; result = total==26"},
{"claim":"Na has fewer protons than Mg so larger radius trend holds (11<12)","code":"Na=11; Mg=12; result = Na < Mg"}
]