Respiratory System
Level 4: Application (Novel Problems)
Time: 60 minutes
Total marks: 50
Answer all questions. Show reasoning; apply concepts to unfamiliar contexts.
Question 1 — Altitude physiology (10 marks)
A climber ascends from sea level to 5,500 m, where atmospheric pressure is roughly half that at sea level.
(a) Alveolar falls from about 100 mmHg to about 45 mmHg. Using the oxygen–haemoglobin dissociation curve, explain what happens to arterial haemoglobin saturation and why the climber feels breathless. (4)
(b) After several weeks, the climber's blood shows increased 2,3-BPG (2,3-bisphosphoglycerate) concentration. Predict the effect on the dissociation curve and explain how this helps tissue oxygen delivery despite the low alveolar . (4)
(c) The climber's breathing rate increases immediately on arrival. Identify the receptors responsible and explain why this response is NOT triggered by the usual central chemoreceptor mechanism. (2)
Question 2 — Pressure mechanics (10 marks)
A patient is stabbed between two ribs, puncturing the pleural cavity on the left side (pneumothorax), while the right lung remains sealed.
(a) Explain, in terms of pressure, why the left lung collapses while the right continues to inflate normally. (4)
(b) During normal inhalation, describe the sequence of muscle action and the intrapleural and intra-alveolar pressure changes that drive airflow. (4)
(c) A doctor applies suction to re-expand the collapsed lung. Explain the pressure condition that must be restored for the lung to stay inflated. (2)
Question 3 — Exercise and the Bohr effect (10 marks)
During intense exercise a sprinter's active muscle produces large amounts of CO₂ and lactic acid, and local temperature rises.
(a) Explain, using the Bohr effect, how these three local changes increase oxygen unloading at the muscle. (6)
(b) The same blood then returns to the lungs. Explain how the reverse conditions in the alveoli favour oxygen loading and CO₂ release. (4)
Question 4 — Comparative respiration (10 marks)
An insect and a fish of similar body mass live in the same pond region — the insect breathes air via tracheae, the fish extracts oxygen from water using gills.
(a) Water holds far less dissolved oxygen than air per unit volume, and is denser and more viscous. Explain TWO structural or functional adaptations of fish gills that compensate for these problems. (4)
(b) Insect tracheae deliver oxygen directly to tissues without using a blood transport pigment. Explain why this system limits insect body size, whereas the fish (with a circulatory system) is less constrained. (4)
(c) State one feature common to BOTH gills and tracheal endings that maximises gas exchange. (2)
Question 5 — Data interpretation (10 marks)
A researcher measures CO₂ transport in venous blood and finds the following distribution of total CO₂ carried:
| Form | % of total CO₂ |
|---|---|
| As bicarbonate () | 70 |
| Bound to haemoglobin (carbaminohaemoglobin) | 23 |
| Dissolved in plasma | 7 |
(a) Write the reversible reaction (including the enzyme) that produces bicarbonate inside the red blood cell, and name the ion movement that follows ("chloride shift"). (4)
(b) A drug inhibits carbonic anhydrase. Predict, with reasoning, how the percentages in the table would change and the consequence for blood pH and CO₂ removal at the lungs. (4)
(c) If total venous CO₂ content is 52 mL per 100 mL blood, calculate the volume carried as bicarbonate. (2)
Answer keyMark scheme & solutions
Question 1 (10)
(a) (4)
- At sea level, alveolar ~100 mmHg lies on the flat upper plateau → saturation ~97–98% (1).
- At ~45 mmHg the value falls onto the steep part of the sigmoid curve → saturation drops sharply to roughly 75–80% (1).
- Less O₂ is loaded onto haemoglobin, so arterial oxygen content and tissue delivery fall (1).
- Low blood/tissue O₂ (hypoxia) causes breathlessness/hyperventilation as the body attempts to raise oxygen uptake (1).
(b) (4)
- Increased 2,3-BPG binds haemoglobin and lowers its affinity for O₂ (1).
- This shifts the dissociation curve to the right (1).
- At the tissues, the rightward shift means O₂ is released more readily (unloaded at a given ) (1).
- So even though loading in the lungs is slightly reduced, tissues still receive adequate O₂ because unloading is enhanced — a beneficial compensation (1).
(c) (2)
- Peripheral chemoreceptors in the carotid and aortic bodies detect low arterial (1).
- Central chemoreceptors respond mainly to CO₂/H⁺ (pH), not to low O₂; at altitude CO₂ is actually washed out by hyperventilation, so only the peripheral (O₂-sensitive) receptors drive the initial response (1).
Question 2 (10)
(a) (4)
- Lung inflation depends on negative (sub-atmospheric) intrapleural pressure which keeps the lung pulled against the chest wall (1).
- The stab lets air into the pleural space, so intrapleural pressure rises to atmospheric (1).
- The pressure gradient holding the lung open is lost, so the elastic recoil of the left lung makes it collapse (1).
- The right pleural cavity is a separate sealed compartment, so its negative pressure is intact and that lung continues to inflate normally (1).
(b) (4)
- Diaphragm contracts (flattens/moves down) and external intercostals contract, raising the ribcage up and out → thoracic volume increases (1).
- Increased volume lowers intrapleural pressure (more negative) (1).
- This lowers intra-alveolar pressure below atmospheric (1).
- Air flows down the pressure gradient into the lungs (1).
(c) (2)
- Air must be removed so intrapleural pressure becomes sub-atmospheric (negative) again (1), restoring the gradient that holds the lung expanded (1).
Question 3 (10)
(a) (6) — award 2 marks each factor (mechanism + effect):
- CO₂: high CO₂ forms carbonic acid → raises H⁺; this lowers haemoglobin's O₂ affinity → curve shifts right → more O₂ released (2).
- Lactic acid / low pH: increased H⁺ directly reduces Hb affinity for O₂ (Bohr effect) → more unloading (2).
- Temperature: higher local temperature lowers Hb O₂ affinity → rightward shift → more O₂ delivered to hard-working muscle (2). (Overall: right shift = more O₂ unloaded exactly where metabolic demand is highest.)
(b) (4)
- In the alveoli CO₂ diffuses out into the air, lowering blood CO₂ and H⁺ → pH rises (1).
- Higher pH / lower CO₂ increases Hb affinity for O₂ (leftward shift / reverse Bohr) (1).
- High alveolar plus increased affinity → O₂ loads readily onto Hb (1).
- As O₂ binds, it promotes CO₂ release (Haldane effect) allowing CO₂ to be exhaled (1).
Question 4 (10)
(a) (4) — any two, 2 marks each:
- Large surface area: many filaments and lamellae maximise area for the low O₂ content of water (2).
- Counter-current flow: water flows opposite to blood, maintaining a diffusion gradient along the whole length so more O₂ is extracted (2).
- Thin lamellae / short diffusion distance or continuous one-way ventilation to move viscous dense water efficiently (2).
(b) (4)
- Tracheae rely on diffusion of gas to reach cells directly (1); diffusion is only efficient over short distances (1).
- A large insect would have tissues too far from tracheoles for adequate O₂ supply, limiting body size (1).
- The fish has a circulatory system with haemoglobin that actively transports O₂ throughout the body, so distance is not a limit and larger size is possible (1).
(c) (2)
- A very thin, moist exchange surface / short diffusion distance (1) with a large surface area maximising diffusion (1). (Either point stated as the shared feature earns the marks.)
Question 5 (10)
(a) (4)
- Reaction: (2).
- HCO₃⁻ diffuses out of the red blood cell into plasma; to maintain electrical balance Cl⁻ moves in — the chloride shift (2).
(b) (4)
- With carbonic anhydrase inhibited, HCO₃⁻ formation slows, so the bicarbonate % falls (1).
- More CO₂ stays dissolved / bound to Hb, so those fractions rise (1).
- Less buffering of H⁺ via bicarbonate route changes handling of acid; CO₂ conversion is impaired so CO₂ removal at lungs is reduced (CO₂ retained) (1).
- Retained CO₂ forms more acid → tendency toward lower blood pH (respiratory acidosis) (1).
(c) (2)
- Bicarbonate = 70% of 52 mL = mL per 100 mL blood (2).
[
{"claim":"Bicarbonate CO2 volume = 70% of 52 mL = 36.4 mL","code":"total=52; frac=0.70; result = (frac*total == 36.4)"},
{"claim":"CO2 fractions sum to 100%","code":"result = (70+23+7 == 100)"},
{"claim":"Dissolved plasma CO2 volume = 7% of 52 = 3.64 mL","code":"result = (0.07*52 == 3.64)"}
]