Understand free cash flow and FCF yield

2.5.12 · Stock-Market › Financial Ratios

Why Free Cash Flow Net Income Se Zyada Matter Karta Hai

Accounting profit (Net Income) misleading ho sakta hai kyunki:

• Non-cash charges jaise depreciation reported profit ko kam karte hain lekin bank account ko touch nahi karte
• Aggressive revenue recognition earnings ko inflate kar sakti hai cash actually aane se pehle
• Capital Expenditures (equipment, buildings kharidna) balance sheet pe capitalize hote hain, isliye poora cash outflow Net Income mein kabhi nahi aata — sirf ek slice (depreciation) baad mein dikhti hai

Free Cash Flow accounting games ko cut through karta hai. Ye jawab deta hai: "Business ne actually kitna cash generate kiya jo discretionary use ke liye available hai?"

WHY investors care karte hain:

1. Dividends aur buybacks FCF se aate hain, accounting profit se nahi
2. Debt repayment ke liye cash chahiye, earnings nahi
3. Valuation: Companies ultimately utni worth hoti hain jitna cash woh owners ko return karengi

Free Cash Flow Ko First Principles Se Derive Karna

Step 1: Operating Cash Flow (OCF) Se Shuru Karo

Operating Cash Flow = cash jo core business operations se generate hota hai (Cash Flow Statement pe milta hai).

$\text{OCF}=\text{Net Income}+\text{Non-Cash Charges}+\text{Changes in Working Capital}$

WHY ye step? Net Income mein non-cash expenses (depreciation) include hoti hain jo profit kam karti hain lekin cash drain nahi karti. Hum unhe add back karte hain. Hum receivables/payables/inventory (working capital) ke changes ke liye bhi adjust karte hain — agar inventory badhti hai toh cash kam hota hai.

Step 2: Capital Expenditures (CapEx) Subtract Karo

Capital Expenditures (CapEx) = cash jo long-term assets (factories, equipment, technology) pe kharch hota hai business ko maintain aur grow karne ke liye.

WHY CapEx subtract karein? Ye cash free nahi hai — ye business chalane ke liye pehle se committed hai. Agar tum equipment maintain nahi karte, business deteriorate ho jaata hai.

Formula

Alternative forms jo tum dekhoge:

• Unlevered FCF (debt payments se pehle) = FCFF = FCF to the Firm
• Levered FCF (interest ke baad) = FCFE = FCF to Equity (shareholders ke liye jo bachta hai)

Hum Levered FCF pe focus karenge (woh cash jo equity holders ke liye available hai sabhi obligations ke baad).

FCF Yield Ratio: FCF Ko Ek Valuation Tool Banana

FCF hona great hai, lekin kitna stock price ke relative mein?

WHY ye ratio? Ye woh cash return hai jo tumhe milta agar tum poori company ke owner hote. Ise bond yield ki tarah socho — jitna zyada utna achha (tum invest kiye gaye har dollar ke liye zyada cash pa rahe ho).

HOW interpret karein:

• FCF Yield > 5%: Generally attractive (company apne price ke relative mein meaningful cash generate karti hai)
• FCF Yield < 2%: Expensive (tum har dollar of cash generation ke liye bahut zyada pay kar rahe ho)
• Negative FCF Yield: Company cash burn kar rahi hai (red flag jab tak ki ye growth investment phase na ho)

Kisse compare karein:

• Earnings Yield (E/P): FCF Yield stricter hai kyunki ye CapEx account karta hai
• Dividend Yield: FCF Yield dikhata hai kya possible hai; dividend yield dikhata hai kya paid hota hai

[!example] Example 1: TechCorp Ke Liye FCF Aur FCF Yield Calculate Karna

TechCorp ke liye given data (FY 2025):

• Net Income: ₹5,000 crore
• Depreciation & Amortization: ₹1,200 crore
• Change in Working Capital: -₹300 crore (inventory aur receivables badhe)
• Capital Expenditures: ₹2,500 crore
• Share Price: ₹800
• Shares Outstanding: 100 crore

Step 1: Operating Cash Flow Calculate Karo

$\text{OCF}=\text{Net Income}+\text{Depreciation}+\text{WC Change}$ $\text{OCF}=5,000+1,200+(-300)=₹5,900\text{ crore}$

WHY ye step? Hum accounting profit ko actual cash mein convert kar rahe hain non-cash depreciation add back karke aur working capital ke liye adjust karke (woh -₹300 crore matlab cash operations mein tie up ho gaya, available cash kam kar raha hai).

Step 2: FCF Paane Ke Liye CapEx Subtract Karo

$\text{FCF}=\text{OCF}-\text{CapEx}$ $\text{FCF}=5,900-2,500=₹3,400\text{ crore}$

WHY ye step? Hum woh ₹2,500 crore remove karte hain jo equipment kharidne/upgrade karne ke liye already committed hai. Bacha hua ₹3,400 crore truly "free" hai.

Step 3: Market Cap Calculate Karo

$\text{Market Cap}=\text{Price}\times \text{Shares}$ $\text{Market Cap}=800\times 100=₹80,000\text{ crore}$

Step 4: FCF Yield Calculate Karo

$\text{FCF Yield}=\frac{\text{FCF}}{\text{Market Cap}}\times 100\%=\frac{3,400}{80,000}\times 100\%=4.25\%$

Interpretation: TechCorp mein invest kiye gaye har ₹100 ke liye, company ₹4.25 free cash generate karti hai. Ye ek moderate yield hai — na amazing, na terrible. Tum ise compare karoge:

• Risk-free rate se (government bonds ~7%)
• Industry peers se
• TechCorp ki historical FCF yield se

[!example] Example 2: Do Companies Ka Comparison — RetailCo vs. GrowthStart

RetailCo (Mature Business):

• High FCF Yield (10%) = invest kiye gaye har ₹100 ke liye ₹10 generate karta hai
• WHY? Established, low growth, minimal reinvestment needs
• Investor appeal: Cash cow, likely dividends pay karta hai, kam risky
• Risk: Growth stagnant ho sakti hai

GrowthStart (Tech Startup):

• Negative FCF (-1%) = har ₹100 market value ke liye ₹1 burn kar raha hai
• WHY? Heavy CapEx infrastructure mein invest kar raha hai, market share chase kar raha hai
• Investor appeal: High growth potential agar profitability tak pahunche
• Risk: Cash run out ho sakta hai, dilutive financing ki zaroorat pad sakti hai

The Lesson: FCF Yield mein "higher = better" akele mein nahi hota. Context matter karta hai:

• Value investors high FCF yield prefer karte hain (RetailCo)
• Growth investors negative FCF temporarily tolerate karte hain (GrowthStart) agar revenue scale ho rahi hai

[!example] Example 3: FCF Yield vs. P/E Ratio — The Trap

Company: DebtHeavy Inc.

• Net Income: ₹1,000 crore (profitable lagti hai!)
• Operating Cash Flow: ₹2,200 crore
• CapEx: ₹2,800 crore
• Free Cash Flow: ₹2,200 - ₹2,800 = -₹600 crore (cash burn ho raha hai!)
• Market Cap: ₹20,000 crore
• P/E Ratio: 20,000 / 1,000 = 20 (reasonable lagta hai)
• FCF Yield: -600 / 20,000 = -3% (red flag!)

WHY ye disconnect? Net Income sirf depreciation reflect karta hai (past CapEx ka ek slice), is saal nayi assets pe kharch kiye gaye poore ₹2,800 crore nahi. Company profitable lagti hai lekin actually cash-flow negative hai kyunki heavy current CapEx income statement ko kabhi touch nahi karta.

The Fix: Hamesha FCF check karo. Low P/E ek value trap ho sakta hai agar FCF negative hai.

Common Mistakes (Steel-man the Wrong Idea)

[!recall]- Feynman Explanation (Ek 12-Saal Ke Bachche Ko Explain Karo)

Imagine karo tum ek lemonade stand chalate ho. Din ke end mein, tum apne paise count karte ho:

• Tumne lemonade bechke ₹500 kamaye (revenue)
• Tumne lemons, sugar, cups pe ₹200 kharch kiye (costs)
• Tumne ek nayi juicer bhi ₹150 mein kharide (capital expenditure)

Tumhara profit (net income) = ₹500 - ₹200 = ₹300. Great! (Dhyan do: juicer yahin subtract nahi hota — accountants uski cost ko kai dinon mein "spread" karte hain ek chhoti "wear-and-tear" charge ke roop mein, ek saath nahi.)

Lekin ruko — tumne aaj juicer pe actually ₹150 kharch kiye. Toh tumhari jeb mein actual cash = ₹300 - ₹150 = ₹150. Ye tumhara free cash flow hai — woh paise jo tum kuch bhi karne ke liye use kar sakte ho: candy kharidna, bike ke liye save karna, ya apna stand expand karna.

Ab, agar tumhara koi dost tumhara lemonade stand ₹3,000 mein kharidna chahta hai, toh FCF Yield hai ₹150 / ₹3,000 = 5%. Tumhara dost ₹3,000 pay kar raha hai har saal ₹150 paane ke liye. Kya ye achha deal hai? Depends! Agar savings account 7% de raha hai, tumhara stand "expensive" hai. Agar doosre stands sirf 3% dete hain, tumhara ek bargain hai.

[!mnemonic] FCF Yield Yaad Karo

"Cash After Capex, Per Price Paid"

• Cash = Operating cash flow se shuru karo
• After Capex = Capital expenditures subtract karo
• Per Price Paid = Market cap se divide karo

Ya: "FCF = OC - 💰Ex" (Operating Cash minus Money for Equipment)

Connections

• Cash Flow Statement: Jahan OCF aur CapEx milta hai
• Price-to-Earnings Ratio (P/E): FCF yield ko earnings yield se compare karo (P/E ka inverse)
• Dividend Discount Model (DDM): FCF sustainable dividends ka source hai
• Return on Invested Capital (ROIC): High FCF + high ROIC = great business
• Enterprise Value (EV): Capital-structure-neutral valuation ke liye EV/FCF use karo
• Working Capital Management: WC mein changes directly OCF aur FCF affect karte hain
• Capital Expenditure (CapEx) Analysis: Maintenance vs. growth CapEx samajhna
• Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Valuation: Intrinsic value find karne ke liye future FCF project karta hai
• Stock Buybacks: FCF se fund hote hain; FCF per share badhata hai
• Debt Service Coverage Ratio: FCF ko debt obligations cover karni chahiye

#flashcards/stock-market

Concept Map